up
beside me, alert and on guard—“we, I
mean, I just wanted to see what was out
here. Since the summer.”
“Uh-huh,” the officer said, putting out
a hand. “ID.”
He made us open our wallets and
show our driver’s licenses. Jamie wore
a deathly stare in his photo, like he’d
been planning to set a pipe bomb in the
DMV. I looked inexplicably sad in mine,
which was strange, as I remember being
pretty happy that day, the day I got my
driver’s license.
Seeing our IDs—that we were both
17, and both local—the officer seemed
satisfied enough, though he still wanted
us off the property. He said he’d
remember us. He’d remember and arrest
us for trespassing next time.
He motioned for us to start walking,
ushering us toward the gated entrance,
where we’d parked.
I found myself lagging so I could keep
pace with the officer, leaving Jamie
alone up ahead, the officer’s flashlight a
white-hot force against his narrow back.
“Officer Heaney,” I said, “were you
around here over the summer? When the
girl went missing?”
With the light on Jamie and not on me,
I could see more of the officer’s face
now, making him less of a uniform and
more of a person. Only, Officer Heaney
was nondescript in the way middle-aged
men often are, with their bloated,
stubbled faces and their shedding heads.
I wouldn’t recognize him out of uniform.
He could be anyone.
I noticed Jamie slow down a little
ahead of us, listening. But I had to ask,
even if Jamie heard me.
“Which girl?” the officer said in a
low voice.
He said it like there could be a great
many girls, a whole jumble of thin,
coltish legs and heads of long, blown-
out hair, and I could select the one I most
wanted from a model casting. He was
only testing me. He knew which girl.
“The girl who stayed here over the
summer,” I said, and then let the name
stumble off my lips for the first time.
“Abby
Sinclair. Abigail Sinclair, I
mean. The girl who disappeared.”
The officer was moving us quickly off
the property. As we passed the naked
flagpole, its rope hanging slack and then
flowing upward with the wind, I caught
Jamie glancing back at me. His face had
gone bone-white in the beam of the
flashlight, a piece of understanding
settling there. He now knew why I’d
stopped the van, that I’d planned this and
kept it from him.
The officer had stopped mid-step, as
if trying to decide what he could say, but
when he spoke, it was with recognition
and with authority, like I didn’t have a
legal right to ask for her by name. “Yes,”
he said. “Abigail Sinclair. Why are you
asking about her?”
I didn’t like the way he said her name.
“She’s an”—I was avoiding Jamie’s
gaze—“old friend of mine. I heard she
was up here this summer, and then I
heard what happened, and I thought I’d
come here and look around . . .”
The officer nudged me to walk faster.
We’d passed the compost now and were
coming up close to the front gate. “From
what I understand,” he said, “you’re
looking in the wrong place.”
I shivered from the slap of a cold
breeze. My feet had gone numb, and I
was almost surprised to look down and
see I did still have my boots on, and not
Abby’s flip-flops, because I could have
sworn my bare toes were buried in
snow.
“What do you mean, the wrong
place?”
“The girl ran off. Her family knows
that. Everyone knows that.”
“You’re wrong. She didn’t run away.”
“You sure about that?”
I was, all at once.
We’d reached the chain-link fence out
front. He held it open with an arm out
level with my chest, and there seemed to
be a fraction of a second when he was
keeping me from stepping through the
broken gate.
“ I know her,” I said lamely. “I know
she wouldn’t.”
Jamie spoke up, surprising me.
“Didn’t anyone see anything? Where she
went? Who with? Anything?” He gave
me a sidelong glance, assuring me