You had the name of being a top hand. Now youâre in trouble. We
can
send you to the pen, and you wouldnât cotton to that any more than me.
âBack yonder when I nabbed you, I could have shot you and nobody would have cared or even asked how come. I didnât. I took you in without a fight.â
âYou was slick. I got to admit it. And I was too damn sure of myself.â
âWell, whatever. Thing is you know Iâll play square if thereâs a way I can do it, and Iâm not against givinâ you a break if you come clean. You know a good deal more than youâve said. You tell me and Iâll try to talk Johnson out of pressing charges.â
Kim stared into his coffee cup, and Chantry felt sympathy for the man. Right now Baca was trying to study out how much he could trust Chantry.
âAll rightâ¦Youâve been square. Trouble is I donât know muchâ¦Only that somebody stole that sorrel before I could. Right from under my nose.â
âDid you see it done?â
âNo, I never.â
âDo you know who did it?â
That hesitation again. âNoâ¦no, I donât.â Kim put down his cup. âLook, Marshal. I stood around the street watchinâ for that horse ân rider. They never showedâ¦and then I saw the rider.
âSo whereâs the horse? I studied on that, anâ knowinâ which way the man would come into town, I started studyinâ on places that horse might be. I pegged it for one of two places. Either that stable with the corral and the two-room shack over east or Mary Ann Haleyâs.â
The shack over east would be Johnny McCoyâsâ¦but why Mary Annâs?
He asked the question, and Baca shrugged. âHe went thereâ¦that rider did. He went mighty early in the morning when they arenât receivinâ guests as a rule, only they let him right in.
âI figured they knew him, the way they opened up for him, so I checked their stable. No horses but their driving horses for their rig. So then I went to the other placeâ¦That horse was sure enough there, but I heard stirrinâ around inside and I took myself away from there.â
âAnd then?â
âI come back that night, real lateâ¦and I seen a man ridinâ off on that sorrel, slippinâ off mighty quiet-like. I know a thief when I see one, and that man was a thief.â
âWould you know him if you saw him?â
âNâ¦no. No, I donât think so. He was kind of humped over in the saddle soâs you couldnât make out his height.â
Borden Chantry opened the cell door and stepped out, closing it after him. âTake your time with the coffee, Baca, and give it a thought. Youâre a good man on a trail. You help me, and Iâll help you.â
He went into the street and stood there, pulling his hat brim down against the glare. A wagon was coming slowly up the street and Johnsonâs dog got up lazily and moved out of the way.
Well, what did that get him? That Mary Ann Haley had seen the dead man. Had welcomed himâ¦or somebody hadâ¦like a friend.
He shook his head. That didnât jell with what he already knew or surmised about the victimâ¦What business could he have with a woman like Mary Ann? That early in the morning when they werenât in the habit of receiving guests?
He tried to add it all up, and came to nothing. âYouâre not much of a detective, Borden,â he told himself.
A stranger had ridden into town with a poke of money, gold, probably. The following morning he was deadâ¦murdered. His horse had been taken out and killedâ¦the brand cut away.
Two things he knewâor was sure of in his own mind: The murderer was a local man, and he had not wanted the victim identified.
Which made the brand all-important.
He turned to start down the street and came face to face with Frank Hurley.
Hurley made as if to turn away but Chantry saw