Was? You guys divorced?â Matt inquired.
I shook my head in no specific direction. Like one diagonal nod maybe.
âHe died?â Matt asked.
In a moment that seemed eternal, I thought about Mattâs question. If I told him I was still married, he wouldâve likely returned to the stadium for the fourth quarter of the game never to hang up on my answering machine again. If I had backpedaled and told Matt I was actually divorced, his decision to dump me after college would be validated by another manâa man who really had the time to get to know me. A man who went into the relationship with every expectation of being with me forever. And still, that man couldnât love me. My being widowed seemed like a good way to go. It made a statement: the only way my husband would ever let me go is if they pried me out of his cold, dead hand.
Pretending Reilly was dead was just too horrible, though. Perhaps I could live with myself if I had a weekend fling with Matt, but posing as a widow was a line I could not cross.
A decision had to be made fast. Who was I? The faithful wife who had the strength to pass on an irresistible opportunity? Or a lesser version of who I thought I was, someone willing to break the rules for a bit of excitement?
People arenât meant to be sexually monogamous, my Inner Male explained. Itâs not natural to expect people to go through an entire life and desire only one partner.
You do so much for other people. Donât you deserve something nice for yourself? continued Penised Prudence.
The two are completely separate, he continued.
To deny oneself pleasure is to cease to live, my Inner Guy pressed, though this time he had a European accent.
Fidelity is for bores.
Funny how my Inner Male felt completely comfortable weighing in with five opinions on the matter.
Youâre almost forty. How many more opportunities are you going to get? This voice was clearly my motherâs, though sheâd shudder if I ever told her she was part of my internal infidelity pep squad.
Matt must have mistaken my silence as confirmation. âIâm sorry, Malone. That mustâve been tough,â Matt said. âWhen did he die?â
Say something. Say anything.
âTwo years ago. Boating accident. I donât really like to talk about it,â I said.
Not anything! Common Sense shook me by the shoulders.
What had I done?! Poor Reilly doesnât even like boating. He probably went to make me happy, and now heâs dead, Iâm alive and Iâm using his tragic demise to seduce my college flame.
Tell Matt it was a slip of the tongue , my Inner Moron suggested.
Slip of the tongue?! chided Common Sense. He died two years ago in a boating accident is not a slip of the tongue. Just move on and stick with the âI donât want to talk about itâ line. At this point, I thought Iâd never see Matt again anyway. Iâd assumed he was only interested in a one-time thing, which I was seriously considering.
I kept my left hand in my jacket pocket until I was able to wiggle my wedding ring off with the other four fingers. Not easy to do. As I struggled with the removal of the evidence of my marriage to Reilly, I knew I was digging myself deeper into the lie I couldnât stop telling.
When Matt ran to the menâs room, I quickly called Reilly on my cell phone. I knew this was extremely risky, but I needed to hear his voice. Needed to hear that he didnât know what I was up to. Perhaps talking to him would snap me back to reality. Back to sensible Prudence.
âHello,â Reillyâs groggy voice answered.
âSleeping in the afternoon?â I said, a bit too sweetly.
âJust resting,â he said.
Poor choice of words.
âWhatâs up? Why are you calling?â he asked.
âI just miss you, thatâs all. I love you. Do you know that?â
Settle down.
He laughed. âOf course I know it. Isnât the game still