concur,â proclaimed Sergeant Motherwell.
Charles, who had already summed them up as a pair of fools, one pompous and the other sycophantic, protested against their verdict of accidental death. During the time they had taken to move Athol from the lagoon boat to the road, he had been occupied by the disturbing thought that Ellisâs lighthearted suggestion of murder might not be so ludicrous after all.
âBut what about the bullet?â he asked.
Dr Spenser regarded him in a lofty professional manner. âWhat about the bullet?â he queried. He made a habit of making a question of a question. It made him sound omniscient and usually abashed the enquirer.
âYou donât fire bullets at ducks,â said Charles defensively.
âMy dear fellow, these amateurs use anythingârifles, repeaters, pistolsâbut anything at all. Every season there is some fatality orother like this. We had one in this district only two years ago, am I not right, Tom?â
The policeman nodded solemnly. âThat is correct, Doctor. It was a near thing to having the chap up for manslaughter.â
âBut this isnât manslaughter,â said Charles loudly. âItâs murder.â
The doctor looked him over as coldly as though he had been requested to perform an illegal operation. âMy good fellow, thatâs an appalling statement to make. I can only presume that the natural sorrow you are feeling has caused the indiscretion.â
âIndiscretion be damned!â Charles retorted. âNatural sorrow likewise. I never felt any personal regard for Athol in my lifeâand least of all now seeing the mess he has left for me to clear up. So you can cut out any emotion from my attitude. But I say he was murdered and if you two would only do your job properlyââ
âNow, wait a minute,â interrupted Motherwell, drawing himself up like an inflated frog. âWe are prepared to make allowances for naturalâumâshock, shall we say? But you must not talk like that, you know, Mr Carmichael. You canât go making wild statements without the evidence to back them up.â
âWell, what of the bullet, to start with?â
âThat has already been accounted for,â said the policeman with a glance at the doctor.
âNot to my satisfaction, it hasnât,â retorted Charles. âThen what about the season not being open until tomorrow? Yes, I know we shouldnât have been out either, but that is beside the point. In fact, had I but knownââ He broke off, horrified at the words that had slipped out involuntarily. He always panned mercilessly those emotional mystery stories whose writers belonged to what Mr Ogden Nash referred to as the H.I.B.K. school.
Dr Spenser and the sergeant regarded him with puzzled animosity. âWhat I mean is,â he went on lamely, âit is unlikely that any sportsman would have been out today other than my uncle, who always made a point of breaking rules. Look at Major Dougallâyouprobably know him as he has been here beforeâhe would not dream of shooting today.â
âJust what are you suggesting, Mr Carmichael?â
âThat someone guessed that Athol was likely to go shooting ducks this morning, and took the opportunity of no one else being nearby to kill him.â
âWhat nonsense!â said the doctor testily. âMotherwell, it is up to you. Iâve given you my opinion as a medical man, but yours is the final word.â
The policeman said with ponderous dignity, âI can only presume that Mr Carmichaelâs imagination is running away with him. I shall put in a full report concerning this distressing affair; naturally there will be an inquest. Mr Carmichael need have no fear that this business will not be wound up entirely to the satisfaction of unbiased authority. But such wild talk of murder cannot be condoned. I must request you, sir, not to voice such fantastic