were watercolours that had been done on ordinary copy paper which had curled a bit as they dried. But though the medium was a subtle one, there was little restraint in the images depicted. The predominant colours were dark, deep bruise blues, slate greys interrupted by splashes of arterial blood red. So violent were the brush strokes that at first Jude thought she was looking at abstracts. But closer scrutiny revealed that the paintings were representational.
Each picture showed the body of a woman, young, shapely, but twisted with pain. Their features were contorted as they struggled against restraints of chain and leather, the red gashes of their mouths screamed in silent agony. But a defiance in their posture and expressions diluted their bleakness. There was suffering there, but also a sense of indomitability. Tormented as they were, Fennel Whittakerâs women would not give up anything without a fight.
âAnd these are recent works?â
âYes. All done since our last session.â
A week then. âYouâve been busy.â
A shrug from the massage couch. âWhen Iâve got ideas I work quickly.â But the way she spoke was at odds with her words. She sounded apathetic, drained, only a husk of her personality remaining after the threshing storm of creativity that had swept through her body.
âWell, theyâre very good,â said Jude. âA lot of pain there.â
âYes,â Fennel agreed listlessly.
âDonât you get a charge from knowing that youâre doing good work?â
âI do while Iâm actually painting. I look at it and it feels right. Every brush stroke is exactly where it should be. I feel in control. Then I look at it a couple of days later and . . .â She ran out of words.
âAnd what?â
âAnd I think itâs derivative crap. I can see the style Iâm imitating and Iâm just deeply aware of all the other artists who have done it better over the centuries, and all the artists whoâre even doing it better now.â
âHave you always had that kind of reaction against your work?â
âUsually.â
âAnd does it ever change?â
âHow do you mean?â
âDo you ever come round to thinking what youâve doneâs rather good again? Do you recapture the feeling you had while you were actually painting it?â
Fennel Whittaker sighed. âHas happened. Thereâs some stuff I did during my first year at art college . . . before I . . . you know . . . I felt pleased with it . . . and one of my tutors, Ingrid, who I really rated, she thought it was great. Yes, some of thatâs bloody good.â
âDoesnât knowing that cheer you up?â
âNo. It makes me feel worse, if anything.â
âWhy?
âBecause I look back and I think: God, the girl who did that had a lot of talent! Unlike the girl whoâs looking back at the stuff. Whatever it was I may once have had, I think Iâve lost it.â
âYou do know that a lot of creative artists suffer from bipolar tendencies?â
âYes. It doesnât help much to know that, though. Doesnât stop me thinking that my workâs crap . . . along with everything else in my life.â
Jude was silent for a moment, trying to decide what therapies she should use for the rest of the session. For the time being, though, she reckoned talking was doing Fennel as much good as anything else would.
âIs there anything specific thatâs made you feel down at the moment?â
âThereâs never anything specific. Itâs just . . . everything.â
âAre you sure about that?â
âWhat do you mean?â
âI know Iâve asked you this before, but are you sure there wasnât something in your past, something that happened that triggered the depression?â
âAnd as Iâve answered