suspicions about her already.
âHeâd always told me that she was a little too aloof,â Sandy said.
Bill had apparently complained to Ken about Nanetteâs lack of involvement in his kidsâ lives and in McLaughlin family get-togethers that past year.
âMy dadâs impression of her from the get-go was that her background didnât add upâthe whole story about the basketball scholarship and [being a] child prodigy,â Sandy said. âHis impression was that she was a gold digger with two little kids, trying to find a rich guy to latch onto.â
Sandyâs father told her that heâd never discussed his impressions with Bill because he felt it wasnât his place. Sandy hadnât said anything to Bill about her perceptions either. However, she, Kim, and Jenny often joked among themselves about Nanetteâs antics and malapropisms, mocking her boasts that sheâd scored a very high score on the Law School Admission Test (LSAT), for which the best possible score was only a fraction of the number she cited.
Nanette also told them sheâd graduated early from high school in Phoenix after playing on the basketball team, then got a basketball scholarship to attend Arizona State University (ASU). There was some photo floating around of her playing basketball, Sandy said, but the girls didnât believe much of that talk either.
âThe tongues would wag behind the scenes when Bill wasnât in earshot,â she said. âKim and Jenny just couldnât stand sitting at the table with her. It was eye-rolling time, because Nanette would try to hijack the conversations and it was usually to talk about her kids or that she could bench-press four hundred pounds.â If everyone else started talking, âshe would just sort of pout.â
To Kim, Jenny, and Sandy, Nanette never seemed very cerebral, which was a marked and rather disturbing contrast to Bill.
âNanette didnât have much intelligent to say at the dinner table or anything, and my dad was a real smart, bright man, and he would love to philosophize and pontificate,â Kim McLaughlin Bayless recalled recently. âPeople would come to our dinner table to discuss business with him because he was very well-respected in our community and with our friends, and he liked to take risks.... I thought it was odd that Nanette didnât take part in many of those conversations. She didnât really say much at all. Maybe she was intimated by us kids, Iâm not sure.â
Other than the obvious physical attraction, Billâs adult children just didnât get what he saw in Nanette. But heâd never said a harsh or critical word about her, and he spoke just as highly of her kids as he did of his own.
Nanette wanted to go grocery shopping that Saturday evening to buy some food for the beach house, so Sandy went with her to Luckyâs, still trying to support the woman she assumed was grieving and eventually would need some comfort. She figured Nanetteâs flat affect was just a mask to cover deeper emotions.
The poor thing, sheâs going to explode.
Looking back later, Sandy said that Nanette seemed âkind of glazed over. It was almost an act.â But at the time, Sandy was simply puzzled by it.
âAt the very least I expected her to be, by that time, upset that her kids had been so close to that kind of danger.â
Sandy just nodded as she listened to Nanette engage in what seemed like âpointless banter.â Nanette said nothing about Billâs death, and made ârobotic-likeâ conversation about her own situation as she threw a box of cereal into the shopping cart for the kids, who were still staying with her ex-husband.
âWhat am I going to do?â Nanette asked rhetorically. âI just donât know what to do next.â
But there was no needy hug, and no emotional explosion.
Well, that was a goddamn waste of time, Sandy thought as