girl.â
Colt took a long pull from his beer and then rested it on his knee, his long fingers gently wrapped around the silver can. I found myself transfixed by them, how smooth they looked. I wondered if they would feel that smooth against my skin or ifâ
âKara?â
My gaze jerked over to him. âUh, sorry, what did you say?â
âI asked if you love him.â
I pulled back. âOf course.â
âBut, are you
in love
with him?â
I glanced away, unable to look at him as he watched for my reaction. Somehow it felt like Colt could see into my soul. Like lying could never be a possibility with him. âCan we talk about something else? I just . . . I canât talk about him with you.â
Colt nodded slowly, understanding what I was saying without making me say the words out loud. I couldnât say them out loud, because then suddenly my feelings would become real and alive and I would be forced to deal with them. He leaned back against the armrest of the sofa and faced me. âMy dad cheated on my mum. It was years ago, when I was just eight, but somehow Iâve never forgiven him. Now that heâs the one whoâs alive, even though sheâs the better person, I find it impossible to be around him. Iâve never hated anyone in my life more than I hate him.â
âIâm sorry,â I said, though I knew it wasnât even close to enough. Simple words didnât erase the pain of losing someone, and saying them felt so very shallow, but I had to say something. Sometimes words were all we had. âLifeâs so shitty sometimes, isnât it?â
âThe shittiest.â
We fell into silence for a moment, sadness swirling all around us, and then he said, âNow itâs your turn.â
âSorry, what?â
âConfess something. Something you donât like to talk about. Something only a few people know.â
My eyes locked on his, fear ripping through me. I couldnât confess about the abortion, not now when Colt had been so kind to me, when he thought I was worthy of someone better than Ethan. If he knew . . . heâd know that I didnât deserve anything at all. Goose bumps rose across my skin as he watched me, and again, I felt the sensation that he already knew my secrets. I cocked my head, glancing from eye to eye as he watched me, and then I straightened, realization and anger coming alive inside me.
Ethan.
âYou know, donât you?â
âI only know what youâve told me, Kara, which isnât much,â he said, but I saw the flash in his eyes. The quick switch, like he was intentionally trying to control his reaction. My stomach dropped.
I studied his expression again, waiting to find some hint that Ethan had told him all my darkest secrets, but nothing came. I relaxed back against the sofa, still uneasy, but I was sure that if he knew, really knew, he wouldnât be able to hold back his judgment.
âI once dated Preston. It was high school and a long time ago. But we kept it from Olivia. She was devastated when she found out. Nearly ruined our friendship forever.â
âWhy did you keep it from her?â
I glanced back over at him, again searching for that telltale look that he knew. Again, nothing. âIt was a long time ago. She was a little broken then, and we didnât want to give her a reason to run away from him. She and Preston are so perfect together. I donât think she would have allowed herself to like him if she knew we were once together.â
âSo, youâre saying youâd do it again. Keep it from her.â
I focused on him. âDonât you think a lie is worth it if the truth would hurt someone?â
âNo. I donât think a lie is ever okay.â
âOh really? So, letâs say a little girl comes up to you on Christmas Eve and asks you if Santa Claus is real. Sheâs all big, hopeful eyes and