back and bit her lip. She laughed slightly.
âThat is such bullshit, Jess Banerjee. Anytime youâve called me itâs been because something was not right with you.â
Her blue eyes accused me. She wasnât wrong.
I smiled.
âLet it go,â I said.
âNo, I want to know.â
âI was fucking bored. I called you because I was bored, all right?â
âAt least youâre honest.â
I sipped my Sauvignon Blanc.
âYou still wear your catâs eye,â she said.
âI do.â
âYou still play with it when youâre uncomfortable.â
I stopped my fingers.
âJess, there are many small things that speak of our past without us having to tell the story of the past.â
âWhat?â
âI will always know you like most people never will.â
âAll right,â I said, âIâll give you that.â
âHowâs Anjali?â
She sipped her wine.
âOkay.â
âWhereâs your mind?â
âHere.â
âYou donât have to tell me.â
âI wonât.â
Tiffany leaned forward and placed a hand over mine.
âJess, why do we even meet? Neither of us seems to enjoy it. Youâre still bitter about what happened.â
âYou cheated on me.â
âI fell in love with someone else. Itâs not the same thing.â
âSeriously, Tiff? Seriously?â
âCan you ever let it go?â
âNo.â
âThen why are we here? What do you want from me if all you give me is hostility?â
âI donât know.â
âThen who knows?â
She placed her wine glass down hard enough to make the table shake.
âEither get past what happened or else donât see me.â
âThose are my two choices, Tiff?â
âBasically, yes.â
âAll right.â
I placed some cash on the table and rose from my seat. She placed her hand over mine.
âLet me ask you one question before you walk out.â
âWhatâs that?â
âHow are you so righteous with me when you cheat on Anjali all the time? Have you ever been faithful yourself?â
I slowly sat back down.
âI was faithful to you,â I said softly.
I felt my heart constrict as if it wasnât four years ago, but four minutes, that I had walked in and found her betraying me, and our lives. I knew that if I closed my eyes, they would be moist, ready to spill my disap-pointment, my confusion, my defeat. So I kept my eyes open, wide open, as if I were indignant instead of hurting, as if there werenât a myriad of questions still burning bright within me, after four years, even after Anjali.
Tiffany tossed back her hair.
âNow donât tell me our relationship turned you from good to evil.â
I cleared my throat, drank some wine.
âI donât think itâs a matter of not being able to be faithful. Itâs just whom youâre with. With you, it came easy. With Anjali, it doesnât. And I donât cheat on her really. Our relationship just changes and we have these moments where weâre not exclusive or weâre trying to be something different. It isnât like it was with you and me. With us, there were rules and boundaries etched in stone. With her and me itâs always fluid, always changing just when it seems like things are a certain way.â
I sipped my drink and thought of my squatting stranger. Could I tell Tiffany?
âItâs cheating, Jess because you know, and I know, that that woman is not going out to screw anyone else whether your relationship is open or exclusive or whatever else. Anjali doesnât just love you, Jess. She worships you.â
âI realize that now,â I said.
And I did, especially after the night we had shared, the proposal, the consummation, once again of our relationship. But when you find your name written on someoneâs heart, scribbled onto the parchment of her soul,