Power, Sex, Suicide: Mitochondria and the Meaning of Life by Nick Lane Read Free Book Online Page A

again, we may not be here to see it ourselves, but intelligent bipeds ought to be able to gaze up at flying creatures, and ponder the meaning of the heavens.
    If the origin of life amidst the fire and brimstone of early Earth was not as improbable as we once thought (more on this in Part 2 ), and most of the major innovations of life on Earth all evolved repeatedly, then it is reasonable to believe that enlightened intelligent beings will evolve elsewhere in our universe. This sounds reasonable enough, but there is a nagging doubt. On Earth, all of this engineering flamboyance evolved in the last 600 million years, barely a sixth of the time in which life has existed. Before that, stretching back for perhaps more than 3000 million years, there was little to see but bacteria and a few primitive eukaryotic organisms like algae. Was there some other brake on evolution, some other contingency that needed to be overcome before life could really get going?
    The most obvious brake, in a world dominated by simple single-celled organisms, is the evolution of large multicellular creatures, in which lots of cells collaborate together to form a single body. But if we apply the same yardstick of repeatability, then the odds against multicellularity do not seem particularly high. Multicellular organisms probably evolved independently quite a fewtimes. Animals and plants certainly evolved large size independently; so too (probably) did the fungi. Similarly, multicellular colonies may have evolved more than once among the algae—the red, brown, and green algae are ancient lineages, which diverged more than a billion years ago, at a time when single-celled forms were predominant. There is nothing about their organization or genetic ancestry to suggest that multicellularity arose only once among the algae. Indeed, many are so simple that they are better viewed as large colonies of similar cells, rather than true multicellular organisms.
    At its most basic level a multicellular colony is simply a group of cells that divided but failed to separate properly. The difference between a colony and a true multicellular organism is the degree of specialization (differentiation) among genetically identical cells. In ourselves, for example, brain cells and kidney cells share the same genes but are specialized for different tasks, switching on and off whichever genes are necessary. At a simpler level, there are numerous examples of colonies, even bacterial colonies, in which some differentiation between cells is normal. Such a hazy boundary between a colony and a multicellular organism can confound our interpretation of bacterial colonies, which some specialists argue are better interpreted as multicellular organisms, even if most ordinary people would view them as little more than slime. But the important point is that the evolution of multicellular organisms does not appear to have presented a serious obstacle to the inventive flow of life. If life got stuck in a rut, it wasn’t because it was so hard to get cells to cooperate together.
    In Part 1 , I shall argue that there was one event in the history of life that was genuinely unlikely, which was responsible for the long delay before life took off in all its extravagance. If the film of life were played back over and over again, it seems to me likely that it would get stuck in the same rut virtually every time: we would be faced with a planet full of bacteria and little else. The event that made all the difference here was the evolution of the
eukaryotic cell
, the first complex cells that harbour a nucleus. An esoteric term like ‘eukaryotic cell’ might seem a quibbling exception, but the fact is that all true multicellular organisms on earth, including ourselves, are built only from eukaryotic cells: all plants, animals, fungi, and algae are eukaryotes. Most specialists agree the eukaryotic cell evolved only once. Certainly, all known eukaryotes are related—all of us share exactly the same