just because it was connected to the murdered writer, but also because there were basic similarities between Rachelâs abduction and that of Lucyâs nephew Justin. Kidnapped from their home in the middle of the night and murdered before dawn. But thatâs where the similarities ended.
Rachel McMahon had been a week shy of her twelfth birthday when she was killed. The killer had raped her in her own bed. According to the autopsy report, sheâd suffered two cracked ribs and had likely been unconscious or unresponsive when Kreig kidnapped her. Though Kreig never once spoke about the rape and murder, Tonyâs theory was that the murder wasnât premeditated. Kreig had planned to rape her, but he thought she was dead or dying. In an effort to cover up his crime, he removed her from her room alive. She died of internal injuries within hours. Had she received immediate medical attention, she might have survived.
Though there was an extensive grid search and numerous volunteers and police looking for her, she wasnât found until Kreig led authorities to her body six days later. However, the coronerâs report indicated that sheâd been dead nearly as long.
MISSING GIRL FOUND DEAD
Rosemary Weber, Senior Crime Reporter
NEWARK, NJâSix days after Rachel McMahon was abducted from her second-story bedroom, her body was found in the woods less than five miles from her home.
Though police refuse to confirm or deny the circumstances surrounding her death and discovery, sources close to the investigation say that her body was located by cadaver dogs in a shallow grave.
The search for Rachel McMahon began last Sunday morning. Her nine-year-old brother awoke during a storm and went to his sisterâs room at three a.m., but she wasnât in her bed. The police contacted friends and neighbors, but no one had seen Rachel.
The investigation was stymied by the missing girlâs own parents, who had a wild party the night she went missing, later identified by this paper as a âswingersâ partyâ where married couples swap sex partners for an evening of drugs, drinking, and sex. Because of the delay in obtaining a guest list, incomplete statements by both Mr. and Mrs. McMahon, and the two-day storm that destroyed physical evidence, the investigation was delayed.
No one has been arrested for the crime, but sources close to the investigation indicate a search warrant has been issued for one of the McMahonsâ guests who has been in police custody for two days.
The Newark office of the Federal Bureau of Investigation, working in close conjunction with the Newark Police Department, devoted all available agents to interview witnesses, process evidence, and search for Rachel. Media Information Officer Special Agent Dominic Theissen stated, âWe are deeply saddened at the discovery of Rachel McMahonâs body late this afternoon. An autopsy and thorough investigation will be completed to ensure that justice will be swift.â
The McMahons were unavailable for comment.
The FBI confirmed that there is no connection between Rachel McMahonâs disappearance and that of Camille Todd, a twelve-year-old girl who went missing from Newark the previous week.
On the surface, the case appeared straightforwardâan eleven-year-old girl had been kidnapped from her bedroom late on a Saturday night. The time of her disappearance was a bit sketchy. No one had seen her between 10:00 p.m. and 3:00 a.m. Her brother told police theyâd been playing games in their playroom until 10:00 p.m. when she went to her room to call her best friend. He fell asleep and woke up at 3:00 a.m. The house was quiet, he went to her room, and she wasnât in her bed. Her friend told police, and phone records confirmed, that theyâd spoken for nearly an hour, hanging up at 11:03 p.m. Rachel wanted to go over to her friendâs house that night, but the mother had forbidden it. For the first day of the