receiving them, she will continue the Circle of Forgiveness, and then some.
âOkay, but the instructions say to send one letter of apology, not a half dozen.â
âYou think Iâve only hurt one person in these seventy-six years? Donât you know, deep inside, weâre all just bundles of shame? I suppose thatâs the beauty of these silly stones. They give one permissionâor perhaps an obligationâto be vulnerable.â
When I arrive late that afternoon, Dorothyâs face has transformed. Her frown lines have softened, and she looks positively serene. She sits in the courtyard, under the umbrella table, with Fiona Knowlesâs audiobook in front of her. I scowl. The girl who treated me so badly is now an icon for forgiveness, and no doubt cashing in, big-time.
âPeople carry secrets for two reasons,â Dorothy tells me. âTo protect themselves or to protect others. Thatâs what Ms. Knowles says.â
âWhat a revelation. The woman is brilliant.â
âShe is,â Dorothy says, obviously not catching my sarcasmâor perhaps choosing not to. âDid you bring my pouches, dear?â
âUh-huh. White tulle,â I say, placing them in her hand. âWith tiny lime-green polka dots.â
She fingers the fabric, and draws open the strings. âBeautiful. Now, thereâs a cup of stones on my nightstand. Fetch it for me, would you, please?â
I return with a plastic cup filled with pebbles. Dorothy pours them onto the table.
âMarilyn gathered these from the courtyard yesterday.â With care, she separates the stones into groups of two. âThis first set will be for Mari,â she says. âThough she doesnât know it yet.â
âMarilyn?â Iâm surprised when she cites her closest and lifelong friend. But on reflection, it makes perfect sense. âWell, I guess when youâve known a person your entire life, youâre bound to have hurt her feelings at one time or another, right?â
âYes,â she says. âAnd it was a doozy.â She closes her eyes and shakes her head, as if the very memory sends a shiver through her.
âIâve always imagined that life is a cavernous room filled with candles,â Dorothy says. âWhen weâre born, half the candles are lit. With each good deed we do, another flickers to life, creating a bit more light.â
âNice,â I say.
âBut along the way, some flames are extinguished by selfishness and cruelty. So you see, we light some candles, we blow some out. In the end, we can only hope that weâve created more light in this world than darkness.â
I pause a moment, imagining my own room of candles. I wonder, have I created more light than darkness? âThatâs a beautiful analogy, Dorothy. And you, my friend, cast a very strong light.â
âOh, but Iâve extinguished my fair share along the way.â She searches until her hand finds another set of stones. âThese will go to Steven.â
âHow charitable,â I say. âI thought you despised him.â
I met Stephen Rousseau twice, when I was dating Jackson. He seemed like a decent man. But Dorothy rarely speaks of her ex-husband, except to say that she has no use for the lout who divorced her nine months after sheâd had a mastectomy. Though three decades have passed, I suspect neither of Dorothyâs scars has fully healed.
âIâm talking about Steven Willis, my former student. He was a bright boy, but his family life was atrocious. I let him slip through the cracks, Hannah, and Iâve never forgiven myself. I think his brothers still live in town. Iâm going to track him down.â
Such bravery. Or is it? Maybe an apology will soothe Dorothyâs guilty conscience, but might it be an unwelcome reminder to Steven of a childhood heâd rather forget?
She moves her hand to the next set. âThese are for