knew, had never returned to Loring.
It was the first mix CD anyone had ever made me. His dad was a lawyer and made good enough money that he had a stereo system with tape-to-tape transfer and a CD burner built in that, more often than not, would tack on the last song three or four times before the CD ran out of space. Jeremy started a CD-burning business for our classmates, which, at ten dollars a pop, paid for more than one date at the one-screen movie theater two blocks from his house.
I opened the case and took out the track list. It was almost all show tunes: âIf Ever I Would Leave Youâ from Camelot; âIâve Never Been in Love Beforeâ from Guys and Dolls; Jeremy singing âAll Through the Nightâ from Anything Goes, his soulful, beautiful tenor distant and obscured by poor recording equipment. But heâd thrown a handful of pop songs on there, too, because it was the late nineties: the gag-worthy âTruly Madly Deeply,â by Savage Garden; Faith Hillâs dippy âThis Kissâ; the 10,000 Maniacs version of âBecause the Nightâ; and â2 Become 1â because heâd had an irrational love for all things Spice Girls. Once, I spent all night by the phone, trying to be caller ninety-seven at Sweet 97.7 to win us tickets to see the Spiceworld tour at Madison Square Garden. I never got the tickets, and anyway, weâd broken up by their July tour date.
Of all the musical-theater nerds in the J. C. Kevlin High School drama club, Jeremy was the most likely to have reallymade it onstage. I hoped he had. I slid the CD into my laptop and hummed along as I searched for him online. And sure enough, there he was, starring as Amos Hart in Chicago . He was there, in my city, doing what he loved. Heâd made it. And maybe, I thought as I yawned and closed my laptop, he might even want to see an old friend.
Chapter 9
EVERYDAY IS LIKE SUNDAY
I was still drying my hair with a Batman beach towel when I answered the door to a starry-eyed Sid, one earbud dangling loose.
âListen,â he said, pressing it to my ear. âDoesnât that just sound like love? Right there, that jangly guitar right before the first verse, thatâs what it sounds like when youâre walking back from a party and youâve just met the love of your life; youâve got a few drinks on your brain and her number on your phone and itâs just the happiest goddamn feeling in the whole world. Bernard Sumner captured that feeling and distilled it down to six minutes and fifty-nine seconds of pure magic.â
I loved the narratives Sid created for his music. It was never just, âI like this songâ; he always had an elaborate scene to describe how it made him feel.
âWhat is it?â I asked. I wasnât as up on my eighties music as I probably should have been, especially for being friends with Sid.
âNew Order, âTemptation,ââ he said, putting one arm around my waist and waltzing me in a circle. âJust hearing it makes my heart swellâIâve listened to it twice since I got off the subway.â
I wished I shared his early-morning musical enthusiasm. I hadnât gotten much sleep after Facebook-stalking Jeremy; Baldrick had woken me up by ramming his hard fluffy head intomine around nine, and it hadnât seemed worth it to go back to sleep if we were going to Egg School at eleven. I had barely put together a decent brunch outfitâa black pleated cheerleader skirt, vintage plaid double-breasted jacket, fourteen-eyelet Doc Martens with rose-print knee socks poking out like I was an extra from Clueless âwhile Sid had on an effortless ensemble of dark blue jeans with the cuffs turned up and a tucked-in flannel shirt in purple and gray check. Anyone else trying to pull it off would have looked like a hipster lumberjack, but Sid carried it off with a cool, straight-backed elegance. He only wore his black-rimmed glasses on