heâs a bore about his cases. And Eliot flees bores as he would the plague. He may be a genius, but heâs a brutally intolerant one.â
âBut, as you say, he likes to surprise people. Eliot canât bear being taken for granted. Heâll always contradict you. Tell him someoneâs a bore, and heâll call him a wit. A wit whom only someone as perceptive as Eliot can see. Tell him someoneâs a genius, and heâll call him an ass!â
âTo prove you an ass. Yes, I see that. But this thing with Tommy seems a bit of a muchness.â
âHasnât Eliot been using Tommy to help him on some legal problem?â
âTrue. But since when did Eliot choose his friends from among his hirelings?â
Well, that was it. I wouldnât admit it to Letty for the world, but I was troubled. I had never made it a secret to myself that I disliked Eliot Amory. He simply possessed too many assets. His blond good looks, his straight, slim, sturdy build, the amiable charm of his glowing good manners, the small, intimate smile that seemed to initiate you into the inner circle of those who really knew what it was all about, the seeming effordessness of his brilliant solution to every offered problem, all enhanced the portrait of a man with spectacular gifts. Why did I smell an arch ego behind his masterful manipulation of his wifeâs enterprises? Wasnât it rather mean of me to feel that only condescension lay behind his genial acceptance of his wifeâs old English teacher? But there you are. I did.
I now began to track the developing intimacy between Eliot and Tommy. It was true, of course, that Eliot had retained Tommy as counsel to the
New Orange Review,
which certainly necessitated a number of meetings, but why did they have to take place at the Newboldsâ apartment?
The Newboldsâ baby, Stephen, of whom Eliot seemed inordinately fond, was naturally his godson and the brightest and most beautiful child anyone had ever seen, but Eliot had never been a noticeably paternal type with his own two children, both daughters, and had seemed quite content with the somewhat perfunctory colloquy that he accorded the girls when the nurse brought them in for a short visit on his evening return from the office. Indeed, Letty had once confessed to me that she feared her failure to produce a son had deeply disappointed him and that she bitterly deplored the ovarian disorder that had caused her doctor to prohibit any try for a third child. Of course, she had quickly added that Eliot had never expressed a word of his regret. Like his recurrent fits of depression, he kept it to himself. The Eliot the world saw was always a cheerful one.
The crisis, as it was for me, anyway, came after a dinner at Alfredaâsâjust the two of us, Tommy being in Albany arguing a caseâwhen she brought me a cognac and closed the door to the library to which we had withdrawn.
âYou and I know each other so well, Hubert, that I can skip the prologue,â she began. âI know what you have guessed, and Iâve known it for some time.â
âWhat have I guessed?â I asked with a sinking heart.
âThat my Stephen is Eliotâs son.â
I gasped as if I had been thrown into churning waters.
âIf that is so,â I finally was able to retort, âwhat business is it of mine? Isnât it a matter between you and Tommy and Eliot alone? If Tommy consented to such an arrangement, mustnât it be kept the darkest of secrets? For I canât imagine that Letty knew! Mind you, Iâm not criticizing you or Tommy. It may even have been, on his part, an example of his magnanimous love for you. But it must never be spoken of!â
âBut Tommy would never have consented to such a thing.â Alfredaâs small smile seemed directed at my naivete. âHe may be brought to accept it after the factâhe might even be glad to have a distinguished father for the