puberty. Our mother did not know how to be anything but beautiful, and she believed that Gretchen must have shared her disdain for the younger, less attractive version of herself, as though the fatness was an unflattering outfit that sheâd simply decided to strip off one morning.
My sisterâs first few years at school were spent trying to blend in well enough that none of her classmates had reason to single her out for ridicule. The strategy was less than successful, because kids donât need a reason to make fun of one another. Just as Abby put up with her fair share of teasing for being so tiny, Gretchen went through elementary school as one of the token fat kids. Some of the older boys on the school bus even made up a song about her, which they sang every morning as she walked to her seat as though it were as mandatory as the Pledge of Allegiance. It was only one line, repeated over and over for as long as it took for my sister to either bury her head between her knees or start crying: âToo many Twinkies ⦠oink, oink!â (They were cruel, but not all that creative.)
During the summer between seventh and eighth grade, Gretchenâs body decided that enough was enough. Over those few months, she morphed into a young bombshell with such alarming speed that our dad insisted she see a gland specialist, even though we couldnât afford it. It was as if she were molting, wriggling a little farther out of her old skin each day, not from effort so much as intuition:
This is what I am meant to become
. She didnât have toput herself on a diet or exercise every day like other girls; she needed only to surrender herself to the genetic lottery whose check had finally cleared. Her unflattering lumps shifted themselves into sleek, symmetrical curves. Her hair grew fast, as thick and long as unspooling silk. Her legs stretched, her shoulders broadened, her spine corrected itself from a slouch to an arch. Twenty extra pounds seemed to dissolve as easily as snowflakes in hot water. When school began the next fall, people whom she hadnât seen all summer didnât recognize her. The Twinkie song was all but forgotten (until two years later, when poor Donny Levin started sixth grade).
It didnât take long for Gretchen to understand that what had once been impossible for herâphysical beautyâwas now effortless. She was thirteen but looked seventeen. She rarely wore makeup, but it didnât matter. Her knowledge of these facts brought power, and with great power comes great responsibility. Unfortunately, because she was still a thirteen-year-old girl, my sister had the emotional maturity of a thirteen-year-old girl. She believed she knew everything about life, when in fact she knew virtually nothing. In short, she was the complete opposite of responsible. And while our father understood that much, our mother wasnât as quick to catch on. Because sheâd been born beautiful, sheâd had plenty of time to grow into an understanding of what such a role required from a person. Gretchen didnât have the first clue.
But she had plenty of opportunities to practice over the next few years, and by the time Steven Handley strolled into our yard to build a retaining wall one hot June morning in 1985, sixteen-year-old Gretchen had been through a handful of boyfriends whohad barely managed to unclasp her bra without hyperventilating. They were nice enoughâshe stayed away from the ones who had teased her most mercilesslyâbut they were all disappointments in their own way: Ben the soccer player had acne all over his back (bacne); Michael the dentistâs kid seemed to have no idea what to do with his tongue besides shove it in her ear; Scott the drummer desperately wanted a mustache but did not possess the necessary ability to grow facial hair, so he constantly looked like heâd forgotten to wipe his mouth after drinking chocolate milk; Greg the future flight attendant had