of the others, the coppery streak of his border braid made bold contrast against the unadorned black that he, like his father, had donned for the morningâs solemn proceedings.
âI know you told me before, but Iâd forgotten that you and Maryse gave one another communion after you made your vows,â Dhugal said in a low voice, looking out at the rain while he fingered the shiral crystal that had been his motherâs. âOf course, you would have. In fact, you were a priest even then, werenât you?âeven though youâd not been ordained or even started in holy orders. Yet you were willing to give it all up for her.â
Duncan sighed and set both hands on one of the horizontal bands of iron supporting the mullioned window panes, leaning his forehead against the cool glass as he stared, unseeing, at the rain beyond. At midafternoon, it was nearly dark already, but not nearly so dark as that dark night of the soul through which he had gone that long-ago summer.
âI thought I was willing,â he said, after a moment. âI fully intended to give it up, at the time. And yet, I suppose I was already a priest. I guess Iâve always known that, but Iâput it aside when I met your mother. I used to wonder if that was why God took her from meâbecause I was His priest.â
âWhy did He let you fall in love, then?â Dhugal demanded. âWas He only testing you? And then, when you failed the test, did He kill her, so you couldnât have her?â
Duncan looked up sharply at the bitterness in Dhugalâs voice, hearing an echo of his own rebellious anger when he learned that Maryse had died.
âDhugal, no!â he whispered. âItâs true that she died, son, but He didnât kill her. If Iâve learned anything in thirty-odd years of living, itâs that Heâs a loving God. He doesnât slay His childrenâthough, for His own reasons, He sometimes lets them suffer adversities that we donât understand. She might have died bearing anyoneâs child. I donât think she was singled out because she dared to love a man God intended as His own.â
As he looked out at the rain again, remembering what it had cost him to truly believe what he had just said, Dhugal snorted and turned away, shoulders rigid with rebellion.
âI understand what youâre feeling,â Duncan said, after a few seconds. âIn some ways, you may be right. It may well be that God was testing meâand that I did, indeed, fail. For a while, after I heard sheâd died, I used to think so. But now I wonder if there wasnât another reason He brought me and Maryse together. He still wanted me for His own, butâmaybe thatâs the only way you could be born.â
âMe?â
As Dhugal turned to stare at him aghast, Duncan smiled gently.
âYouâre so like Alaric sometimes. Heâs another who doesnât like to think heâs been the subject of Heavenâs special attention. Ask him sometime, if you donât believe me.â
âWell, it does take some getting used to.â
âWhy? Donât you think God has a plan for each of us?â
âWell, of course,â Dhugal said uncomfortably. âBut only in a general sort of way. We have free will.â
âTo an extent,â Duncan agreed. âBut what was my will, set against the will of God, Dhugal? He wanted me to be His priest. Iâm not sure I ever had a choice in the matterânot really. Not that I mind,â he added. âNot now, at any rate, and not for many yearsâthough I certainly minded after your motherâs death.
âBut thereâs a certain heady comfort in knowing one has been chosen, warts and all. I donât know why He wanted me so badly, but other than that one brief flare-up of rebellionâwhich may have been all in His plan anywayâIâve been content in His service. No, more than