straining to hear her much quieter voice. âKyle Bennett? What the hell are you doing here?â
Why had she answered to
Mina
? Why didnât she say that she was
Noel
, that he somehow had the wrong person?
âItâs not like that,â he said, raising his hands up in surrender. âIâm not here to start trouble. Trust me, if thereâs one thing I regret in my life, itâs the trouble Iâve already caused you. Thatâs the last thing I want right now.â
âSo what
do
you want? I havenât been back to Green Hill or seen your face in nearly eighteen years, and now youâve somehow found me and are pounding the buzzer at my front door. Why? What could you possibly want from me now?â
Green Hill
. He was from Green Hill? It was where my mom and dad had both grown up, a small town somewhere on the Philadelphia side of Pennsylvania. I didnât know much about it; my parents didnât talk about Green Hill often, and weâd never visited. My momâs parents lived in Jersey now, my dadâs in Florida, so there wasnât much cause. Momâs sister, my aunt Gracie, was in Texas for grad school, and her only two friends from the Green Hill daysâher only friends at all, really, other than the characters who filled her headâmy âauntsâ Izzy and Hannah, had moved away, too, after college. Green Hill had always sounded like a quaint, rustic old country village to me, like something from a folktale. Not a place that still existed for my parents, or for me.
But it did still exist, clearly. This man was proof.
âOh, Mina,â he said, his voice breaking as he clawed his hands through his hair. âMina . . . My babies. We wereat Disney. When it happened. Parker, though, he . . .â Kyle sobbed, sagging forward until he fell down onto his knees. âWe lost Parker right away. But Ella is still hanging on. Just barely at times, it seems, but my little angel isnât giving up easy. My wife had some burns, too, but nothing life threatening. And IâI came out of it without a scratch. Not a single goddamn scratch. Itâs not fair. Why couldnât it have been me at least?â He lost it completely then, slamming his fists against the cement steps, a broken strand of
why, why, why
spilling out with his tears.
My mom ducked her head down, concealing her face from me. There was a long pause before she spoke again. âIâm so sorry, Kyle. I canât imagine what you must be going through right now.â She took a few tentative steps forward, slowly reaching one arm out to rest on his hunched shoulder. âI will keep Ella in my prayers.â She paused, waiting as his sobs slowed. âI donât mean to be insensitive, but . . . I still donât understand why you came to New York. I donât understand why you came to
me
.â
âBecause I know, Mina,â he said calmly, wiping at his tears as he raised his eyes to face her. âI know that you never lost the baby. I know that you came here to protect her.â
My mom said nothing to this, made no movement. He lifted her hand from his shoulder and clasped it between his palms, shifting himself until he was bowed down before her. âGod is punishing me, Mina. Heâs punishing allof us, using the Judges to do the work. And I feel like these horrible things have happened to me because . . . because of how I treated you. Because I refused to believe in you. But Iâm sorry now, Mina, Iâm so sorry. I need you and your child. Donât you see? Youâre my only chance at the miracle I need to save my little Ella.â
âI donât . . .â my mom started, backing away. He clung to her hand, dragging his knees along the cement to follow her. âKyle, this is insane. I donât know what youâre talking about. I lost my child that day. Everybody knows that.â
My mom