wouldnât go that far, but it does have a ring to it, donât you think?â Seth leaned forward and took a sheet of paper from Harlandâs desk. âMay I?â
âBe my guest. Youâre going to show me the equation?â
âNo. Iâm going to translate it into a hypothetical syllogism of sorts.â He spoke his argument as he wrote it out in longhand.
(A) If an all-knowing God exists, then he knows precisely what THE future is. (He knows whether Iâm going to cough in ten seconds.)
(B) If God knows what THE future is, then that future WILL occur, unless God is mistaken. (I WILL cough in ten seconds.)
(C) Because God cannot be mistaken, there is NO possibility that any other future, other than the one future that God knows, will happen. (Thereâs NO possibility I wonât cough in ten seconds.)
(D) THEREFORE, if God exists, there is only ONE future, which is THE future he knows. (I cough in ten seconds.)
Seth set the pencil down. âBasically, if God exists, the probability of there being more than one possible future is zero. And vice versa. To believe God exists also requires you to believe that the future is unalterable. By definition. There can only be one future, and no amount of willing can change it.â
âAnd the ramifications of this theory?â
âReligion has no purpose.â
âKnowledge of fact doesnât necessarily prove singularity of future.â
âYouâre only splitting hairs between knowledge of fact and probabilities.â
Harland nodded slowly. Theyâd argued the subject on several occasions, and he didnât seem eager to dive in again.
Seth looked out the window. âYou should reconsider deismââ
A pigeon slammed into the window with a loud thunk .
Seth blinked. âOuch. Youâd think that would break the window.â
âWhat would?â
Seth looked at him. âThe force of the bird slamming into the window.â
Harland looked at the window. âWhat bird?â
âWhat do you mean, what bird? You didnât just see that?â
âNo.â
Seth looked at the window. âYou didnât hear a loud thunk just now?â
âNo. I didnât hearââ
A pigeon slammed into the window with a loud thunk . It fell away in a flurry of feathers.
âLike that?â Harland asked.
Seth stared at the clear pane of glass. Yes, exactly like that.
âHuh. I couldâve sworn I just saw that ten seconds ago. Like a déjà vu.â He shook his head.
âYou okay?â
âYeah.â Odd. Very odd.
âAnother year here and youâll be out,â Harland said. âStay with it.â
Seth sat back. âNow youâre sounding like Clive Masters.â
âAnyone with half a brain would say you should finish.â
âSo youâre saying . . . ?â
âPlay ball at the reception Thursday. Smile, be nice. Try to keep your foot out of your mouth. Maybe even offer some kind of apology to Baaronââ
âSuck up.â
âIn the vernacular.â
âBe reasonable and do whatâs best for everybody.â
âYes.â
Seth stood and walked to the window. His fingers slipped into his pocket and toyed with the Super Ball. The pigeon was hobbling along the grass, dazed.
âI wouldnât dream of anything else, Professor.â
chapter 6
t he bruise on her face was hidden from Samir, but he had to know something terrible had happened by the tremble in her voice. The tragedy was too large in her mind to discuss at firstâthey rode in silence.
Miriam had awakened in the car and wept for her friend. At home, her father, Salman, refused to hear anything of it, insisting that if it had happened as she said, the matter was beyond his influence. She went to her room and fell asleep on a pillow soaked with tears. Sheâd heard of stonings and even drownings before, of course, but only in stories