beginning of a thought about women alone in their rooms in the bright mornings, fretting over men and boys, but the receiver came alive again. âOkay,â said Mrs. Pfaff, squaring herself to the task. âYou there?â
âIâm here.â
âHere we go. Red-light schools: Amherst Princeton Penn Cornell. Yellow light: Middlebury Tufts Bates Hamilton Davidson. But Middleburyâs orange, if you can believe it. Whatever that means. Green light: Denison Champaign-Urbana St. Lawrence Elon. I mean, Elon ? What is Elon ?â
âUp-and-coming, small, North Carolina.â
âWell, yeah. No. I mean, Gerry went to Cornell, and donât tell him I told you this, but it always smarted because he wanted to go to Yale. And now this. I donât think sheâs factoring in Hunterâs tennis. And what about peer counselor? There are only twelve of them, you know, six boys and six girls. Itâs a big, big honor! So I just, I donât know what to think!â
What Anne thought is that Hunterâs school college counselor was spot-on, but her loyalty mustnât seem shaky. âWhatâs the counselorâs name?â she asked.
âTiffany Schmitz.â
Anne knew just the one. She was a pro. âAll right, donât panic,â Anne said. âTiffanyâs job is to manage expectations. She needs parents to feel that their children succeeded, not failed, right? So sheâs going to go out of her way to be careful with her recommendations. Sheâs not making the decisions here, remember.â
Though, of course, to some extent, she was; Tiffany Schmitz had just signaled to the Pfaffs that she would not be pounding the table for Hunter at Amherst, Princeton, Penn, or Cornell. It would cost her too much with the admissions officers, and there would be other, much stronger candidates in Hunterâs class.
âYeah, I guess that makes sense,â sniffed Mrs. Pfaff. âBut, Anne, what can we do?â
âWell, weâre going to be smart and thoughtful and realistic. Tell me, first, where does Hunter most want to go?â
âOh. Well, weâre just positive Amherst is the best fit for him. I mean, a small school, lots of faculty attention. Hunter really thrives with mentors. Heâs got a cousin there, sheâs going to be a junior, and she just loves it. She tells us all the time that he would be perfect there.â
âHas he seen it?â
âNo, we couldnât quite make it there last summer. Itâs so remote! But he really liked Middlebury when we saw that; we had a wedding in Woodstock, so, anyway, itâs similarâin the mountains, you know, the rural thing, trees. He keeps talking about Montana but thatâs just a nonstarter.â
âAnd the rest of the list? Has he seen any of those?â
âLetâs see, Cornell, yes, with his dad, and Princeton, and Yale, but thatâs off the list. Iâm forgetting the others, but yes, I think he has. No to U of I and this Edon.â
âElon.â
âUh-huh. Oh, and he liked Davidson well enough. Gerry took him to look. Said it was kind of southern, but the tennis might be a good fit.â
It was almost always the case, Anne reflected, that the kids knew where they belonged. If left to their own devices, they rarely set their hearts on impossible schools. âOkay,â she replied. âI think it would be good to think about which schools Hunterâs seen and really likedâwe should put those at the top of our list. Weâll just rewrite it according to his interests, and worry about the red-lightâgreen-light stuff later. Itâs good of Tiffany to be so tough; itâll help us think clearly about all of this. Has Hunter been in touch with the tennis coaches?â
âYes. I called all of them except forâwhat was it?âTufts. Didnât try there. But I mostly left messages.â
âHas Hunter been in touch with
Shawn Davis, Robert Moore
Lessil Richards, Jacqueline Richards