clothes. The father continues to laugh but now seems somewhat repelled by him. Scene goes blank. Curtain comes down. Heâs left looking at the curtain. Or if it is theater-in-the-round, which it resembles more: blackout, and when the house lights come on thirty seconds later, the actors have left the stage. âFrieda,â he says.
âExcuse me,â she says to his mother. âYes?â
âIâm sorry, I didnât mean to break in like that, but thereâs something Iâve often wanted to ask you about from the time when I was around five.â
âYou wanted to ask me it since you were five?â
âNo, I mean, what I want to ask you about happened, or I think it did, when I was around five.â
âHoward,â his mother says, as if saying, since they had talked about it a few times, not to ask it.
âWhat is it?â Frieda says. To his mother: âWhatâs the big mystery?â
âNo mystery,â Howard says. âJust that your memoryâs so goodâphenomenal, reallyâthat I wondered if you could remember it for me from that time.â
âWhy donât we keep it for lunch,â his mother says. âI want you to join us. Frieda already told me she wants you to come too. Have anything you want.â
âLet me just finish this, Mom. I donât think, if Iâm gauging her right, she wants me to ask this, Frieda. Thinks it might offend you. Believe me, thatâs not my purpose. Whatever happened so long ago is over and past, period. We allâanyway, if it did happen, you were probably doing somethingâI know you wereâthat you thought right or necessary. Or just required for what you were hired for, or something. Iâm not getting this out rightâand I meant by that nothing disparaging about you, Momâbut just know Iâm not asking this with any harm in mind whatsoever. None.â
âWhat could it be? The mystery gets bigger and bigger. That I slapped you a few times? Iâm sorry for that. I never wanted to. But sometimes, sweet and darling as you were, and beautifulâhe was such a beautiful child, everyone thought soâyou got out of control, like all children can. Out of my control.â
âThatâs true. They could be something.â
âI had three very wild boys to take care of sometimes, so sometimes I had to act like that. Rough. Mean. Slap one or the other. I always tried for the hands or backside firstâto get control or theyâd run over me. I had a lot of responsibility taking care of you all. Your mother understood that.â
âI did. I wouldnât have accepted outright slaughter, but certainly corporal punishment is needed sometimes. You must do it with Olivia from time to time, spank her,â she says to him. âLater, against your better judgment, you might even slap her face a couple of times. Youâll see. Children can get to you.â
âI donât know. If I did, Iâd have Denise to deal with.â
âShe too. Calm as she is, and reasonable, sheâdââ
âNo, never. Not her, take it from me.â
âBut with Howard,â Frieda says, âI just hope youâll have forgiven me by now. But if it had to be done sometimes, it had to be done.â
âOf course. Iâm not saying. But I was talking of once when youâat least my second-rate memory tells me thisâwhen you pulled my hair and a big chunk came out. Did it? Where I walked around with a big bald spot for about a month?â
âI donât remember that.â
âNeither do I,â his mother says.
âTo be honest, I do remember once putting filth in Alexâs face. He was in the bath. He made in it. Number two. I felt I had to teach him somehow not to. I donât like it now. But that was about the worst I ever did, I think. In ways I donât like most of it now, but then I was so much younger, a new