course. Of course it had. How could it not?
âHave somewhere to be?â Juanita asked Max, seeing him look toward the door.
âW-well, I did planââ
âYou planned what exactly?â Juanita said sharply.
I drew back, pressing my shoulder into Haileyâs so hard that I could feel her bones. It was rare for Juanita to take this tone with anyone, but I had heard it a few times before, when sheâd felt the need to defend me and Hailey against other peopleâs hurtful behavior. That was when her claws came out.
I didnât want a fight. I didnât want anyone to make any points. All I wanted was for Max to leave, and as quickly as possible.
Max looked at her uncertainly, and before he could come up with any response, Juanita took a quick swerve in her tactics. Her smile turned mischievous. âWhat are you so nervous about anyway?â she asked, teasing him. âNever been alone in the dark with four girls before?â
âEr, no, I justââ
âOh, for Godâs sake,â I burst out, âstop trying to mess with his head. He doesnât have to go to the stupid observatory.â
Juanita raised her eyebrows at me. âOh, now itâs the stupid observatory?â
âLeave him alone,â I repeated lamely.
My gut twisted. Why didnât he just leave? Why couldnât this just be over now?
âItâitâitâs okay,â Max said. âIââ
I was such a fool. The truth was that from the moment when Max had smiled at me in class that morning, there had been a part of me that had imaginedâwhat? Surely not dating him, but . . . Having him smile at me again? Having him become my friend? My incredibly cute friend who made my breath catch with every one of those thousand-kilowatt smiles?
But even that had been a fantasy. Iâd imagined that just because he was so good-looking, he must be extra good inside too. See, thatâs the thing about our species. We can kind of tell the difference between looks and personality, but only kind of. Weâre always getting the two things mixed up in our heads, even when we know better. Thatâs part of what makes it so hard for people to accept me and Hailey, and it was that very same flawed thinking that had made me fantasize some kind of connection with Max.
But here he was, completely flustered by Haileyâs simple suggestion that he come out with us as a group, and after all, the chances were that he was just another skittish, reputation-protecting jock. He was probably afraid of what people would say if he went up there with us.
âItâs too bad,â Hailey said. âYou didnât seem so scared of us when you first walked in.â
For a long, drawn-out moment the whole Sandwich Shack fell absolutely silent. Bridgetâs eyes were wide, and her mouth had fallen open in shock.
Juanita waved a hand in Maxâs direction. âOh, forget it,â she said. âJust forget it.â
Max said, âI jââ
âI said forget it. Weâll see you around.â
She waved at the door. I was frozen, waiting for him to leave so that maybe, just maybe, I could finally breathe again.
He looked like he wanted to say something. But whatever it was, he didnât say it, and then the moment passed. He stood up, and as he did, his face seemed to contort into a strange, rigid anger. I pulled back in alarm; it was as if heâd turned into a different person from the wind-tousled, broadly smiling guy who had walked in here just a few minutes earlier.
Max turned to look at each of us, one by oneâJuanita, Bridget, then Hailey, and finally me. With his eyes on me, he opened his mouth as if to speak, but no sound came out, and then he shut it again. He seemed to be as mute with fury as I was with fear.
He shoved his chair too hard into the table, with a loud screech and a clatter. He turned away, grabbed his backpack from the floor, and