Mommyâs place. She had acted as if it were not at all strange that Mommy was upstairs in bed at dinnertime, instead of at the kitchen table eating meat loaf with her husband and daughter. Laura drank all her milk and ate all her peas and hoped that being a good girl would make everything all right.
Laura had also pretended not to notice that Daddy was drinking even more than usual.
For as long as she could remember, Daddy drank from the red-and-white cans. Mommy usually didnât say anything, but Laura could tell that her mother was keeping track of the âred-and-whitesâ piled up in the trash can each day. âEmmett, thatâs enough, honey,â sheâd say. Usually, Daddy would stop.
With Mommy unable to keep watch now, Daddy didnât stop. He drank more and more. He slurred his words. He smelled like beer. Sometimes heâd stumble and fall when he got up from his chair.
One night, Laura said, âDaddy, thatâs enough, now.â And her father hit her. After that, Laura pretended not to notice as she heard one beer can after another pop open.
Somehow, even in her little girlâs mind, Laura had known that her father had not meant to hit her. He loved her. She knew it. She excused him because she knew that Daddy was worried about Mommy.
She knew because she had heard him. When her parents thought she was safely sound asleep in her room, blond, wispy-haired Laura stood in the hallway outside her parentsâ door and listened to their hushed voices.
âOh, Sarah, what will I do without you?â Daddy cried.
âShh, sweetheart, shh. Iâm so sorry, so sorry. But you have to be strong, you have to go on, for our little girl, for Laura.â
âI canât.â
âYes, you can. You must. But, Emmett, youâve got to stop drinking. Promise me youâll get help.â
Laura heard her father whimper and it scared her. If Mommy was leaving her, all sheâd have was Daddy, and he was falling apart. Daddy, who sheâd always thought was so big and strong. Daddy, whom sheâd have to depend on to make everything all right. Daddy, who was sobbing.
âPromise me, Emmett. You have to tell someone. Unburden yourself. Youâll never be able to stop drinking with what happened nagging at your conscience. You have to stop feeling guilty and own up to it. Admit to what happened. It was an accident. Go to the police. Confess.â
Laura knew what âconfessâ meant. She had made her First Holy Communion that yearâand along with it, her first confession, the other sacrament, Penance. She had had trouble coming up with things to tell the priest, things that would be considered sins.
She stood in her flannel pajamas and bare feet, and wondered, What did Daddy do that Mommy is so worried about?
Twenty years later, a childhood and adolescence of secrets and physical abuse behind her, Laura still did not know what her mother had been whispering about. But her forehead carried a constant reminder of her fatherâs sickness and inability to control himself.
14
D R . L EONARD C OSTELLO finished his rounds at Mt. Olympia Hospital with a heavy heart. But it was not his last patient, a teenage girl who had been knifed in the face by some lunatic in Central Park, that left him feeling bereft. When he was done with her, several operations and many thousands of dollars later, she might even look better than she had before.
Costello walked slowly down the hospital hallway, the antiseptic scent of recently cleaned linoleum filling the air. Nurses hurried down the hall, their crepe-soled shoes squeaking. Doctorsâ names crackled over the PA system. But Costello was only faintly aware of the activity around him. He was thinking of his conversation with Gwyneth Gilpatric and it was deeply troubling him.
Did she know? How could she know about the Parkinsonâs? He hadnât told anyone, not Francheska, not even his own wife.
He had taken