flashed briefly again and Mitch was confused to feel himself respond to her obvious pleasure. âSo, you were already on your way! Thatâs wonderful!â She clasped his jaw in her hands and kissed him so quickly that Mitch didnât have time to step away.
He stared down at her, hearing his heartbeat thunder in his ears. She must be a nut. There was no other possible explanation for her behavior.
Because Mitch knew that there was no such thing as witches, and certainly no such thing as spells that actually worked.
âI guess I didnât have enough faith, after all these years,â she confessed with glowing eyes. âIâm so sorry I underestimated you.â
Mitch pushed a hand through his hair, not quite certain where to start in untangling this womanâs misconceptions. âLook. I donât actually know you,â he said firmly but gently. To his relief, she didnât interrupt. âI canât apologize enough for my behavior - it was wrong.â
âIt was perfectly right,â she breathed, then smiled again. âAnd thatâs why you couldnât stop yourself.â She nestled closer and clasped his neck, stretching to kiss him again.
But Mitch evaded her touch as he frowned anew, disliking an intuitive sense that she had hit the nail on the head. âIt canât have been right,â he argued carefully. âBecause Iâve never met you before in my life.â
Her calm confidence didnât waver, much to Mitchâs dismay. She arched one dark brow, as though amused by his protest. âWhich particular life do you mean?â
âWhat was that?â
âJust because we havenât met in this life, doesnât mean we havenât met before.â Her tone was surprisingly matter-of-fact. âYou may not remember, but I certainly do.â
She remembered all her past lives. Oh boy, loony tunes. Mitch should have paid more attention to that sign. There was no way he would be able to argue his way free of this one.
âLook. Believe it, donât believe it. We all make our choices,â he said lightly. âIâm your new neighbor and thatâs it as far as Iâm concerned. No past lives, no previous scores to settle, or bad karma leading to lives as cockroaches. I donât do mumbo jumbo. One life is just plenty for me.â
âSo very practical,â she teased with soft affection. âWhy were you knocking on my door, then?â
Mitch wished that knowing little smile of hers didnât make him want to kiss her quite so badly.
âMy stepmother has this idea that people who tell fortunes are perfectly sane,â he confessed. âI came over here to prove her wrong.â He didnât finish the argument, he didnât think he needed to and he didnât want to be rude.
But the lady didnât seem to get his inference, which surprised Mitch. There was something in those eyes that made him think she didnât miss much.
Mitch pointed in the direction of the neon sign. âYou would be the Lilith of Lilithâs Lovematches ?â
Her sudden smile was dazzling, and she stuck out her hand in turn. âLilith Romano: tarot card reader, matchmaker, small business owner, damn good cook.â She quirked a brow. âAnd perfectly sane, by all accounts.â
She was charming, Mitch had to concede that. âExcept for one small kink in the belief system?â he dared to suggest.
Lilith laughed. The sound was rich and rippling, it made Mitch want to laugh along with her. âSpeak for yourself,â she retorted.
Mitch couldnât completely stop his unwilling smile at her stubborn consistency. Nor could he refuse to shake Lilithâs proffered hand.
It would have just been rude.
But he wasnât expecting her touch to send an army of little tingles over his flesh. The sweet recollection of Lilithâs kiss flooded his mind once more, his gaze dropped to her lips in