concrete than unfounded suspicions to make him investigate the case properly.â He blew out a mouthful of smoke in an irritated sigh. âI wish Superintendent Ashley was here but heâs on holiday. I got to know him last year. There was a murder over in Breedenbrook.â
Smith-Fennimore turned round. âWas that the business the newspapers called The Fortune Tellerâs Tent Mystery? You were caught up in it, werenât you?â
Haldean nodded. âThatâs the one. After that, I know Ashley would take me seriously. As it is . . .â He shrugged. âIf thereâs anything to find, weâll have to find it.â
âUs?â Smith-Fennimore looked startled. âWhat do you want us to do? I donât know what to look for. Iâm not a detective.â
Haldean gave a faint grin. âItâs not so very complicated.â He walked across the room and propped himself against the mantelpiece. âThe first thing we do is to go back to last night. Arthur, when was the last time you saw Tim?â
âCrikey, Jack, I donât know what time it was. I didnât look at my watch.â
âWell, how soon before the fireworks was it?â
Stanton frowned. âIt canât have been long. I came in from the terrace to the hall and saw Tim going up the stairs. He told me Lyvenden wanted his cigarette case.â His face cleared. âThatâs right. Then I went back to the ballroom, saw you and we stood together to watch the fireworks.â
âAnd neither of us saw him again. Did you see him, Fennimore?â
Smith-Fennimore shook his head. âI saw him earlier in the evening, but I was talking to Sir Philip for quite a while before the fireworks started. I certainly didnât see Tim then. Mind you, I wasnât looking for him especially.â
âHe didnât watch the fireworks,â said Haldean thoughtfully. âDo you remember when Lord Lyvenden was making his speech? He suddenly decided Lady Harriet needed her shawl. He looked round the crowd and I thought he was looking for Tim.â
âThatâs right, Haldean,â agreed Smith-Fennimore. âNow you mention it, I thought much the same thing. He sent Lady Harrietâs maid, didnât he?â
âThatâs right. So, as Arthur saw Tim go upstairs just before the fireworks and as he wasnât there during the fireworks, letâs assume for the time being thatâs when it happened. It certainly fits in with what the doctor said. Now, if Tim was murdered, the murderer came into the room with him. Did they leave any traces?â
Smith-Fennimore raised an eyebrow. âCigar ash and footprints, you mean? This is Sherlock Holmes and no mistake.â
âPerhaps it is,â said Haldean with a fleeting smile. âLetâs look. Incidentally, Fennimore, do you know anything about this gun?â He picked it up from the desk and handed it to him. âGeneral Flint had a good look at it last night so even if there were any useful fingerprints on it, they wonât be there now.â
Smith-Fennimore reached his hand out for the gun. âItâs Lyvendenâs,â he said. âIâve seen it before. He always kept it in his desk.â He pulled a face. âI remember Tim commenting on it. The poor beggar knew it was there all right. Doesnât that scupper your murder theory, Haldean?â
âNot necessarily. The gun could have been on the desk or if the drawer was open it could have been visible.â He smiled deprecatingly. âThereâs another fairly obvious explanation but the great thing in this game is not to jump to conclusions too early and to collect what evidence we can.â He looked at Stanton and Smith-Fennimore. âEr . . . shall we start?â
The three men began to look round the room.
Stanton stood by the fireplace. For Jackâs sake heâd go through with this charade, but it was a