her. Of course she knew exactly what was said; she was just too embarrassed to respond to it.
Weâre so happy to have you here.
âWeâre so happy to have you here!â Paul stated triumphantly.
Gaia lowered her eyes. Her face felt hot. She was blushing. She couldnât remember the last time she had felt so bewildered and happy at the same time, as if she were five years old. But she didnât want to fight the emotion. She wanted to drink it in, thirstily, like wine.
âChill, bro,â Brendan joked. âSave it for the bonus round.â He glanced at Gaia. âYouâll have to excuse my brother, Gaia. He doesnât get out much.â
âReal funny,â Paul replied with a smile.
An awkward beat passed.
Gaia looked up and saw that Mr. and Mrs. Moss werenât smiling at all. Maybe there was a little toomuch truth to that statement. Mrs. Moss had said that Paul was living at home instead of at his Columbia dorm and that she could hear him crying at night behind his closed door. And when Gaia turned to Paul again, there was still a smile on his faceâbut there was undoubtedly something else behind it. A sadness in his eyes. Somebody would have to look closely to see it, but Gaia had done just that. And seeing that unbearable emptiness just beyond his functional surface was very much like having a mirror on the other side of the dining table.
âWell, Iâm going out
tonight,
â Paul muttered after a moment.
âOh, yeah, thatâs right,â Brendan said. âGaia, thereâs a Fearless show at CBGBâs tonight. Youâve got to come with us.â
âSure,â she agreed absently, her mind drifting into the past. âGod, I havenât been to a Fearless show since Mary and Iââ
She cut herself off instantly. Maryâs name had not been mentioned once. Sitting in the sudden awkward silence, Gaia wondered if sheâd just made a massive errorâperhaps the biggest error a person could make in the Moss household.
âGaia,â Mrs. Moss said gently, as if reading her mind, âwe talk about her all the time. We talk about her as often as possible, and you should feel free to dothe same. I know you loved her as much as we did. As much as we
do.
â
Gaia nodded and swallowed, then allowed herself a small sigh of relief. Talking about Mary was something Gaia would have never allowed herself to do alone. But in a way, that was what Maryâs gift had always been to her: the chance to do something she never would have done aloneâwhether it was going to a Fearless show, wearing a tight red dress, playing a game of truth or dare, or just listening to someone elseâs problems instead of dwelling on her own.
âI did,â Gaia said, just barely holding off another wave of emotion. âI mean, I do. But my point is this,â she announced, squelching every ounce of her sadness. She replaced her wimpy self-pitying tone with something bold and absurdly declamatory. âTonight. . . I must
rock.
â
Everybody stared at her.
Then Paul laughed. So did Brendan. Mrs. Moss cracked a puzzled smile.
It was an unquestionably stupid thing to say, but somehow Gaia knew that Paul would think it was funny. And that was precisely why she had said it. If she could make a member of the Moss family laugh, then she knew she was doing something worthwhile.
From:
[email protected] To:
[email protected] Time: 6:48 P.M.
Re: The truth
Gaia,
I hated what happened this morning. It hurt more than you can imagine. But I know itâs my fault. Because you donât trust me. And why should you? Iâve been lying to you, and I know you can tell. But Iâve only been lying to protect you. You have to believe that.
Iâm in real trouble, Gaia. And I think you may be, too
Gaia,
I have to see you tonight. I know you think Iâm a liar, but thereâs so much you donât know. I want to