continued to select as assisting bishops to Cardinal Boyle the most conservative of nominees.
McNiff conjured up the image of a prizefighter, a boxer, carrying his opponent. Rather than allowing the opponent to fall and thus ending the match, he keeps the adversary standing while continuing to punish him.
Is this what had been going on over the past few years?
McNiff did not want to believe it, but at this moment, it seemed the best explanation.
âIf you wish, Father,â Boyle broke into McNiffâs mental musings, âyou may think and pray over your decision for a few days. Take a week, if you find that necessary. Then come see me again.â
âThank you, Eminence. Iâll get back to you as soon as I can. Surely within a week.â
Six
âIf I hadnât quit smoking years ago, I might just light up now.â Father Koesler spoke only half in jest.
âIsnât it niceââMcNiff paused to blow his noseââisnât it nice,â he repeated, âto know that you have some corroboration for your theory about the conservative auxiliaries? Not to mention the reason the Pope keeps rejecting the Cardinalâs resignation?â
âYeah, thatâs nice.â¦â Koesler paused. âHow many people have you told?â
McNiff shook his head and gestured: âYouâre it.â
âI can see why.â
McNiff nodded. âIt would have been counterproductive. We felt that the longer the facultyâand the students, for that matterâwere in the dark about the real reason Iâm here, the more chance of success Iâd have.â
âYou couldnât even let the minority liberals in on it?â
âUh-uh. They might have reacted with some wink-and-nod body language that would have tipped the whole thing off. This transformation had to be imperceptible, not apparent ⦠you know, just a gradual kind of thing, for it to work.â
âWell, Iâll give you that.â¦â Koesler leaned back in his chair. âItâs going so gradually that no one in the diocese seems to be detecting it. Youâve been here over five years and I havenât heard anyone comment on any kind of change going on here whatsoever.â
âThere have been changes.â McNiff sounded a whit defensive. âI admit theyâre subtle. A couple of the priest faculty are goneâone to a pastorate, the other to Senior Priesthood. Three of the lay staff have left. And Iâve replaced them all. No â¦â McNiff shook his head and waved his hand in a negative gesture in response to Koeslerâs obvious heightened interest. â⦠not with crashing liberals, but with conservatives who have that needed touch of tolerance.â
McNiff began to cough, blessedly not in the direction of Father Koesler, who felt he would be fortunate to escape this bug-filled space without contracting pneumonia.
âSo,â Koesler said finally, âas far as you know, there are two, and only two, who are in on your secret mission: you and the Cardinal.â
âUntil this moment, yes.â
âOkay, youâve told me. Now, isnât it possible that the Cardinal has let someone else in on it?â
âThe understanding is that we would share this knowledge with no one without informing each other. And the agreement affects me mainly. Iâm the one on the firing line. I need more mobility in handling this policy.â
âSo youâve told Boyle about our meeting tonight?â
âIâll tell him tomorrow.â
Koesler paused, giving himself time to assimilate all this. âOkay,â he said, finally, âI guess that brings us logically to the ultimate question: Why me?â
âExactly.â
Koesler noticed that McNiffâs eyes were bloodshot and his face was puffy. He wondered whether this cold, or fluâwhateverâhad been at least partially brought on by the stress of this