hear of their antics. Lahr had a strong baritone voice; his balladry and his aloofness earned him the reputation of a âcharacter.â He was never unaware of the group sentiment toward himself, and he allowed his friends to create a role for him. He liked to make them laugh, often revising popular songs for comic effect. The role brought an easy but satisfying security.
Lahr still found himself drawn to the theaters for excitement and escape. âWeâd have to walk two miles to the McKinley Square Theater and the Boulevard Theater. On the other side of the park was the Crotona Theater and there I saw Willie Howardâs brother, Sammy. The theater was over in the Jewish section, and it was a Jewish audience. He was with the Newsboy Trio, I think. They did an imitation. In those days, the dance craze was the âTexas Tommy,â which was like the âFrugâ or the âMonkeyâ today. They used to have troupes of âTexas Tommyâ dancers. The Newsboy Trio performed the dance as well as imitating the format of the amateur-night routine. At the finish, theyâd have all the amateurs line up on the stage. If the prize was five or ten dollars, theyâd put the money over the amateurâs head. The audience would judge who was the best. Every time it came over a new head, the audience would applaud. When they put the money over Sammy Howardâs head, he went down to the footlights and said, âIch bin ein Yid.â Naturally, he won. I screamed, the incongruity of it. Iâve remembered it all these years.â
The Bronx did not change Lahrâs life as Augusta and Jacob had hoped. He brought to his new home the same vacancy and irresolution. âI went alone a lot of the time. Always alone. Proctorâs 125th, Proctorâs 58th, Minorâs 153rd ⦠Iâd go all over the city if I could get my hands on a quarter. I loved the theater, not for me to get into, but the acts. I was entranced by them. It was just entertainment for me. Barber shops in those days used to get free passes to the shows for displaying posters announcing the acts. Every time Iâd see a billboard in a window, Iâd go in and buy the passes from them. Theyâd sell for a dime or a nickel. I walked all over. In those days, youâd walk great distances to save a nickel.â
Other incidents assured Lahr his reputation for eccentricity. âThe Fairmont A.C. was down on 138th Street. My pal was Joey Berado, who liked to box, and I was his second. All I knew was I had to fan him with a towel. All the kids who wanted to box used to go down there and theyâd give them fifty dollars worth of tickets. Youâd sell the tickets to the boys (two dollars a ticket and you got half). One day when we were down there Eddie Glick came in. He was sort of a dull-witted guy and a plumberâs helper. He said, âI get six dollars a week, and Iâm loosening toilets and radiators. Iâd like to make a few bucks. Iâd like to fight.â So we said, âSure. Go down and get the tickets and weâll train you.â He got the tickets and started training. I said, âWe got a new way of training. Eat cheesecake and beer and run aroundCrotona Park.â He did. He could get cheesecake for a dime and beer we all drank. Heâd run around Crotona Park. After four days, he came to us. âIâm sick,â he says. âThatâs what we want, itâs getting the bad blood out of you.â We finally got him a fight against a little kid from Christâs Church. Heâs been doing this for a week but nobodyâs been teaching him how to box or anything. He came in the ring, and I went over to the opponent and said, âThis guy canât take it in the stomach.â The kid from Christâs Church comes out, feints him, and punches Glick in the belly. He threw up all over the ring.â
His friends found Lahrâs humorous incompetence often