If she listened to everybody whose child had not been stolen, well, they all had spidey sense, got a feeling, saw a look, thought they could figure it out. It must have been someone the child knew who grabbed him! Or else why hadnât he cried? Why hadnât anyone seen? And how long does it take for a grown woman to find a freaking quarter? And why hadnât she locked her door anyway?
Now, Carrie was standing in the kitchen entry, listening to Johnâs car screech into the driveway, door slamming, feet running, trying to use his key and realizing the front door wasnât locked, just like the car. Knowing she hadnât listened to his repeated warnings. Carrie tensed inside, waiting for him to yell at her for that too. Everybody said the same things to her: She needed to lock the doors to keep people out but open her heart to talk to them, to help them, to let them in. But how on earth would she know the difference between who to keep out and who to let in?
Inside, Johnâs face was paler than usual, a trickle of sweat sliding down one of his dark sideburns. He put the bag from the farmersâ market on the coffee table.
âYou stopped for food?â she said incredulously.
âI went out earlier,â he said. âPut it in the office fridge.â
She stood in the entryway of the kitchen. âHeâs in here,â she said, as if he couldnât see that.
He stepped in. âOh my God.â His voice cracked. âBenny boy,â he said softly.
âDaddy, Daddy!â
Ben ran to him, wrapping his arms around his fatherâs khaki pants, burying his face between his knees. Is he smelling us too? Carrie wondered . Inhaling the memory of metal, the steam iron hovering over the fabric? John closed his eyes for just a moment, as if his lonely knees had missed his son, then bent over and picked him up.
Ben had a face full of Johnâs featuresâsmall nose, dimpled chin. But his coloring was lighter, more like Carrieâs, as if someone had mixed in sunlight. The best of both families, Carrieâs mother said once to Johnâs mother, and Johnâs mother had agreed. Carrie couldnât always trace the good in her own family tree, but Ben had it. He had the sweetness, the light, that she remembered from her own early youth.
âYou see what I mean,â Carrie said.
John held him aloft, smiling, then tossed him, caught him, wild giggles in the air. He was both loving him and testing his weight.
He glanced at his wife but didnât say anything. Didnât want to tell her the truth: that he didnât remember, that some of the details of his son had slipped away, that he had changed the wallpaper on his phone to a picture of Ben just to help him stop that erosion but that it seemed impossible. John carried Ben past the small island, past the pantry door with the vintage Eat sign on it.
Carrie eyed the half-open pantry door. There, on the molding, the pencil lines that were fading and a little smudged, the evidence even John couldnât bear to paint over, to erase. They both knew they would own the molding of that door forever, with the marks of their sonâs height.
âLetâs measure him,â she said.
âMe big!â Ben said.
âYes, you are, buddy. Youâre big. Come on, Carrie. Heâs a little bigger; heâs justââ
âNo. Take him upstairs, get the scale. Maybe we should call the pediatrician? Find out what he weighedââ
âNone of that matters, Carrie,â John said. âLetâs call the police, and letâsâ¦just love our son, okay?â
Johnâs eyes met Carrieâs over the top of their sonâs head, and she nodded.
But when she nestled Ben back in her arms, she bounced him, trying to remember how heavy he was before. She thought of every time sheâd strained to pick him up, balancing a shopping bag on the other hip, thinking he was too big to carry