incest.”
“Tony, you don’t have a sister.”
“Yeah, but you have a brother. Does he touch you the way we do?”
She wrinkled her nose. “No, but that’s just gross.”
Tony leaned back against the futon, draping his arms over the back, satisfaction evident in his quirky, one-sided smile. “I think I’ve made my point.”
She thought about how they behaved with the women they went out with. Actually, she hadn’t seen either one of them with dates in a couple of years. She knew they dated. They just didn’t bring their women around her. Nor did they talk to her about them, but they had mutual friends who were happy to keep her updated on their relationship status.
Tony continued. “We argued about who’d get first shot at you.”
“Does Jake know about this?”
Mark snorted. “Are you kidding? You were right the first time. He’d throw us in the ocean.”
“So you were joking about the—” heat crept up her neck and face, and she hoped they couldn’t see it in the dark, “—three-way. You just want me to pick one of you.”
“Ah, well, it’s a little more complicated than that.”
“Really?” she asked facetiously.
“Look, we’ve told you how we feel about you, but we don’t know how you feel about us.”
“I do,” Mark interrupted with a smug grin. “I kissed her. She kissed me back. I’m gold.”
Hailey couldn’t help it. She had to knock him off his high horse. “Mark, you are quickly losing your status as the perfect man. And until you kissed me on the plane, I was beginning to consider the possibility that you were gay.”
They stared at her then at each other, speechless for the first time that evening. Good .
Mark opened his mouth to speak twice, but nothing came out.
Tony eyes widened, as if he suddenly understood the meaning behind her statement. “Does that mean you thought I was his…” He stared at Mark then at Hailey. “Lover?”
She nodded. “Yep.”
Nobody spoke. Their expressions were so bewildered that Hailey wanted to kiss them. Hell, she wanted her Hailey sandwich back. Her skin tingled and her pulse accelerated at the thought. As she remembered the feeling of both of their cocks pressed against her, her sex clenched, sending warm liquid trickling into the crotch of her lace bikini panties. She pressed her thighs together, trying to relieve the full ache that begged for their touch. She closed her eyes and bit her lip to stifle the groan that threatened.
She sensed Tony, caught a wisp of his scent before he touched her. As he slipped his hands to her waist, she kept her eyes closed, enjoying the full-body contact. Her nipples puckered, supersensitive, and she wanted him to touch them. Instead, he nuzzled her neck, trailing kisses down the side to her shoulder and pushing the cami’s thin strap down her arm. Her breathing quickened, and she grabbed his hips to counteract the dizziness caused by his touch. She let her head fall back, offering her breasts, and his lips moved lower to the curve swelling out the top of the thin cotton. Just…a few…more inches.
But he didn’t stay there and didn’t go lower. His lips drifted back to her ear, and he murmured, “Not gay.”
She licked her lips and swallowed. No, definitely not gay. And thank the gods for that.
He tried to step away from her, but she kept a tight grip on his hips.
He chuckled. “Looks like I’m golden too.” He pulled her closer and tucked her head under his chin. “So you have a decision to make.”
Mark’s voice, low and tight, drifted to her from the futon. “One of us or both of us. Or…neither.”
Chapter Four
Hailey stumbled into the kitchen without bothering to put on a robe. In loose blue cotton shorts with a yellow daisy print and an oversized white T-shirt that had once belonged to Tony, she followed her nose to the coffee. It was close to noon, and the house was silent. Everyone gone to the beach except her. Nikki had poked her head in this morning and