familyâPeter, Uncle Jim, his wife Thelma, the cousins and their familiesâand she gave the smirky smile Rosie recalled so well from her daughterâs childhood, the smile designed solely to ingratiate, and said, âI wanted to see the family, too, of course. Itâs been so long,â and pulled forward the hairy man who stood behind her like a footman. âThis is my husband, everyone. Ivan Cord.â She waved her skinny hands around like a parody of someone with social graces. âIvan, this is my Uncle Frank, I think ⦠Uncle Jim? My brother Peter. This must be Aunt Thelmaââ
Rosie grabbed Susannahâs arm and turned her around. Though Rosie looked murderous, Susannah kept her smile, as if she was just about to introduce her mother, unctuously, to her husband, maybe even attempt a daughterly embrace. She was all bland affability, and she reminded Rosie at that moment of Edwinâs mother, old Mrs. Mortimer, whose self-satisfaction thinly disguised as goodwill hung around her like smog. Rosie said, âYou donât belong here. This isnât your family any more. And donât call her Grandma , you little bitch,â words that entered the family annals for keeps.
In some part of her, Rosie was horrified to hear herself speak these words. Some tender little fold in her mind wanted her to hug Susannah, to forget everything and resolve to love her. She had just lost her own mother, and here she was driving her daughter away. And part of her also was appalled at the listening silence. She saw her cousin Deborah, with whom she had never gotten along, nudge her paunchy husband and roll her blue-shadowed eyes. Peter touched her shoulderâjust a touch, as if to remind his mother. But she went on, and it was unfortunately true that while parts of her were dismayed, most of her thoroughly enjoyed the scene. She said things she hadnât been able to say when Susannah was a child of ten.
âYou have no right to be here. She wasnât your grandmother. Iâm not your mother. I want nothing to do with you. This isnât your family any more than itâs his.â Rosie gestured toward Susannahâs silent, glowering mate, the ex-priest. âYou get out of here, damn you, both of you. I wonât have you contaminating my last memories of my mother.â
Susannahâs face was red, her smile had slipped away, but she stood there and defied Rosie, just as she used to at seven, eight, ten. âI loved her too, you know,â she said softly. âShe was my Grandma, and I loved her.â
That was when Rosie slapped her. âGet out of here before I strangle you with my bare hands,â she said. Her voice rose, then lowered to a snarl. âGet out, get out, get out.â Rosie could hear it still, could see it as if it were all on film: her hand raised, the palm hitting Susannahâs cheek, the girlâs head spinning to the side, and her twisted mouth, the low chant of âGet out, get out â¦â Susannah looked at Rosie in an odd way. She was angry, of course, and indignant, and stunned, but she also looked, in an instant, teary and woebegoneâa poor-little-match-girl look that might have gone to her motherâs heart if she hadnât hardened it so thoroughly for so long.
Then Susannahâs husband took her by the arm, supporting her with his other hand around her waist, and led her out, both of them strangely silent, unresisting, looking at no one. They went out the open door and down the steps, heads bowed, his arm supporting her. Rosie noticed what thin legs she had and how inappropriately she had dressed, in a garish nylon print wrap-dress with long, hot sleeves. Then they disappeared around the corner to the parking lot.
There was silence for a moment in the church, and no one moved. Then Rosieâs Aunt Thelma said, âWell,â and a buzz of conversation started. Peter put his hand back on her shoulder and