breezy and okay, like their bailing on tradition was not a big deal. For some reason deep inside me, that was importantâthat no one know how my insides were sinking faster by the second, how I felt completely alone.
âSo youâre out too, Iâm guessing?â I asked Eph, my mouth twisting into this phony super-gracious smile.
He gave me a weird look. âWhatâs wrong with your face? And why are you getting all splotchy again?â
âAre. You. Going.â
âSorry.Autumn got us tickets to this interactive Macbeth thing in a warehouse.â
âThat sounds awesome,â I lied.
âTrust me, Iâd much rather hang out with you. Autumnâs in a constant hand-holding phase. It makes my hands sweat.â
He held up his palms, as if to prove his point.
âOkay, okay.â I chewed on my lip, brainstorming. I could fix this. âMaybe we can hang out next Saturday instead. I know, letâs go to Coney Island! Itâll be like the Fall Festival but a little tackier. And with the ocean.â
There. Totally natural, breezy. Nice recovery, self.
Audreyâs face fell. âNext Saturday? I promised Cherisse Iâd go to that new guy Keatsâs First of October party with her.â
Oh.
Keats was having a party.
âFirst of October party?â Eph snorted.
âI would bring you guys, but itâs invitation only . . .â
(Of course it was.)
â. . . and Cherisse has been crushing on Keats forever . . .â
(Of course she has.)
â. . . and itâs this fancy costume party . . .â
(Ugh, so cool. Of course, of course, of course the beautiful new boy would have a fancy costume party.)
At that moment I was seconds away from having a crumbly meltdown about hickeys and festivals and French Club and social circles and the fact that my life was an open book but Audreyâs and Ephâs lives had chapters I wasnât cool enough to read.
My melodramatic subconscious started playing âOne Is the Loneliest Numberâ in my head.
My subconscious is the worst.
âIâll go to Coney Island with you, Pen,â Eph offered. âI heard last week that people got stuck on the Cyclone and had to walk down the hill. How rad would that be?â
âSo rad,â I said hollowly.
Without all three of us there, it wouldnât be the same thing. It already wasnât the same thing.
Plus Keats was having a party.
Forget Coney Island.
I was pretty sure that everything I ever wanted, that everything I was currently missing out on, would be at that party.
A small and terribly traitorous sigh escaped my lips.
At the sound of it, the three of us halted all interaction. Eph frowned and turned back to his notebook, and Audrey tugged so hard on her hair I thought she might pull it all out. Meanwhile, my face was frozen in some uncomfortable, phony lunatic smile.
This was not how our afternoon at Chipotle was supposed to be going.
Be the better person, Pen. You love these people.
âDo you know what youâre wearing?â I asked Audrey, forcing my voice to be positive, willing us all to change the conversation.
âTo Keatsâs party?â she asked, face confused.
âNo, to homecoming!â
Her face broke out in a relieved smile, and she whipped out her phone and flipped through pictures before pointing one out. âHere.Cherisse and I found it at this new vintage shop downtown called Hong Kong Eight.â
The dress was beautifulâa pale, silvery-pink beaded sheath. âVery Audrey Hepburn. Living up to your namesake, yeah? Thatâll be gorgeous on you.â
âSweet,â Eph muttered after giving the phone a perfunctory glance.
Audrey relaxed, explaining how she was going to do her hair (a professional blow-out so it was straight and shiny) and what shoes she was going to wear (silver Mary Jane wedges) and the boutonniere she was buying her