walking through the door at any moment, and that wewill be resuming our lives. But my father never shows up. And every day he doesnât, I withdraw deeper.
Within a year of the trial, donations to my family slow to a trickle and become difficult to live on. My fatherâs friends are still loyal to us (a deliveryman named Mohammed Salameh promises to marry my sister when she comes of age) but theyâre more loyal to the jihad (Salameh will be sentenced to 240 years in prison for his part in the World Trade Center attack before my sister even enters her teens). We move around New Jersey and Pennsylvania constantly, usually because thereâs been a death threat. By the time I finish high school, Iâll have moved twenty times.
We always live in dangerous neighborhoods, without another Muslim family in sight. I get punched and kicked at school because Iâm different, because Iâm pudgy and donât talk much. My mother gets taunted on the streetâcalled a ghost and a ninja âbecause of her headscarf and veil. And there is no permanence to anything. Someone always discovers who we are. The word spreads that we are those Nosairs. The fear and humiliation return, and we move again.
Amidst all this, there is the nonstop emptiness of missing my dad. His absence gets bigger and bigger until thereâs no room in my brain for anything else. Heâs not there to play soccer with me. Heâs not there to tell me how to handle bullies. Heâs not there to protect my mother from the people in the street. Heâs in Attica State Prisonâand wonât be out until Iâm at least fifteen, maybe not evenuntil Iâm twenty-nine. (I do the math in my head all the time.) I tell myself that I canât count on him anymore. But whenever we visit him, hope returns. Seeing the family together again makes everything seem possible, even when it isnât.
â¢Â  â¢Â  â¢
One weekend when Iâm nine, my mother drives us across New York to Attica, which is on the far edge of the state, near Canada. The carâs an old station wagon with fake wood paneling on the sides. My mother has folded the back seats down so we can sleep or play or roll around if we want to. Ever since we left New Jersey, Iâve been bubbling over with nervous energy. This weekend weâre not just going to visit my father in some big, boring room where thereâs nothing to do but play Chinese checkers. This weekend weâre going to âliveâ with my father. My mother has tried to explain how thatâs possible, but I still canât picture it. We stop for groceries along the wayâsomehow or other, sheâs going to cook for us allâand my mother lets me buy a box of Entenmannâs chocolate chip cookies. The soft kind. When we get back in the car, Iâm twice as excited as I was before, thrilled about seeing Baba and about the cookies. My mother looks at me in the rearview mirror and laughs. She never gets to see me happy anymore.
Attica is massive and grayâitâs like the castle of a depressed king. We go through security. The guards inspect everything, even the groceries, which have to be perfectly sealed.
âWe got a problem here,â one of them says.
He is holding up the Entenmannâs. Thereâs something wrong with the box. It turns out that thereâs a hole in the cellophane window on top, so they wonât let me take it in. My eyes start stinging with tears. I know that the minute we walk away, the guards are going to eat my cookies. They know thereâs nothing wrong them.
My mother puts a hand on my shoulder. âGuess what,â she whispers.
If I answer, my voice will break, and I donât want to embarrass myself in front of the guards, so I just look at my mother expectantly until she leans down and says these amazing words in my ear: âI bought another box.â
I run across the grass toward my father.