asked loudly: âHow much more valuable?â
âFifty to seventy dollars difference. Rather a mischievous kind of trick for a spirit to play,â said Gamadge. âMalicious, I call it.â
Miss Higgs spoke in a low, rather husky voice: âLetâs see the thing.â
Gamadge held it up by its top and bottom edges. âNice thing,â he said. âSupposed to resemble Miss Vanceâs great-uncleâs mother. Miss Paxton knew it well; thatâs why she noticed that lettering had sprouted out on it. Sheâs worriedâfeels responsible.â
Mr. Simpson said after a silence: âI thought something was supposed to be lost.â
âWell, thatâs of course the alternative,â Gamadge told him. âThat the pictures were changed. This one was in the house in a kind of book-roomâI mean it may have been. At any rate, the other is goneâeither really gone, or supernaturally changed into what you see. If Miss Vance could tell us by clairvoyance what has happened to it, well, I neednât say what a relief that would be to poor Miss Paxton.â He laid the portrait down again and turned to face Miss Vance. âOr if you canât help her in that way, she thought it was just possible that you might be able to suggest some dealer who would be able to replace the other portrait. She tells me that your father was an artist, perhaps you have some knowledge of this sort. The thing wouldnât be so easy to find. Miss Paxton wondered if you could possibly be persuaded to hunt one up among the galleries. Anything to get it back, you know, without a fuss and complications.â
Simpson had stepped a little forward, but nobody spoke. Then Miss Vance laughed gaily, threw out her arms so that the sleeves floated like wings, and let her hands fall. She said: âThis is stupid. Heâs laughing at us.â
Miss Higgs was scowling. Bowles was shaking his head at Mr. Simpson, but the young man walked up to Gamadge and spoke furiously: âWhat do you mean by all this? Whatâs the idea?â
Iris Vance replied, still gaily, âHe thinks Iâm an underworld character. He thinks I stole the thing. No, really, when you come to think of it, what a joke on me!â
Bowles came forward, a man who seemed to lumber but was light on his feet. He said: âWait a minute, wait a minute,â and went up to the table. He leaned over the engraving, frowned at it, bent to read the lettering. Then he swung on Gamadge. âLetâs hear some more about this. Where was the other one hanging in that house?â
âTowards the rear of the first-floor hall.â
âFramed?â
âFramed.â
âAnd weâre to take your word for it that the frame could have been tampered with?â
âAnd Miss Paxtonâs word for it. My opinion is that it had been tampered with, and recently.â
âThen all this stuff about spirit writing was phony? You didnât mean it? You didnât even expect Miss Vance to fall for it?â
âIt was an approach. It wasnât I, you know, who let in anybody else on our sitting. Miss Vance was free to respond as she chose.â
âWell, of all theââ
Mrs. Spiker now spoke, roughly but with a kind of careless good humor: âDonât waste any of that on this guy, heâs too slick. Iris, go ahead and tell him you donât have to go around picking up fifty dollars that way.â Simpson was about to speak, but she cut in on him: âNo, itâs her business.â
âYes,â said Miss Higgs shortly. âIt certainly is.â
âAnd I could have told you he didnât believe in spirits,â added Mrs. Spiker, âone minute after he came into this room. Look at him.â
âIâm looking at him.â Bowles lowered at Gamadge. âHeâs out to get some picture back, he thinks he has proof Miss Vance has it, and heâll hang on to