truth. âIâm sorry I found her so late, and Iâm sorry the circumstances make life even more difficult for you.â It made life ahell of a lot more difficult for us, too, but this didnât seem like the moment to dwell on it.
âYouâre right, this doesnât look good for us,â Joel said. He took Dianeâs hand. âWe were already under suspicion. Not Felicia, of course, but Diane and I and Victor, and now thatâ¦â He had trouble going on. âNow that her body has been found hereâof all the places on earthâI think the police are going to decide it was one of us all along. I almost donât blame them. It just looks bad. If I didnât know how much we loved Tabithaâ¦â He sighed heavily. âMaybe they think we conspired together to kill our daughter. Theyâre paid to be suspicious. They canât know itâs the last thing in the world weâd do. But as long as theyâre focusing on us, they wonât be looking for the son of a bitch who actually took her.â
âExactly,â Diane said, and her hand rubbed her stomach in a circular motion. I yanked my gaze away.
âHow long have the police suspected you?â Tolliver asked. When weâd been there, Tabitha had been missing for several weeks, and the police hadnât been around so much any more. But weâd been impressed at how cordial the relationship that had formed between Detective Haines, whoâd been the Last Man Standing on the case, and the Morgensterns had seemed. I should have realized that the other cops might have developed other suspicions. Haines had actually gotten to know the Morgensterns a lot better than her associates.
âFrom the get-go,â Joel said, his voice resigned. âAfter nosing around Vic for a while, they got the idea that Diane was guilty.â
I could almost see why theyâd suspect Joel, even Victor. But Diane?
âHow could that be?â I said incautiously, and she flushed. âIâm sorry,â I said instantly. âIâm not trying to dredge up bad memories. I was sure, always, that you and Joel were telling the truth.â
âTabitha and I had a fight that morning,â Diane said. Big fat tears ran down her cheeks. âI was mad because weâd just given her a cell phone for her birthday, and sheâd already exceeded her minutes. I took her cell away from her, and then I told her to go outside to water the plants around the front door, just to get her out of the house because I was so angry. She was furious, too. Spring break, and no way to communicate with her three hundred best friends. She was just into that âMo-THER!â stage, the eye-rolling thing.â Diane wiped her face with Joelâs handkerchief. âI didnât think weâd get to that until she was fifteen, and here she was, eleven years old, giving me the whole routine.â She smiled in a watery sort of way. âI hated to tell the police about this really trivial conversation, but one of my neighbors overheard us arguing when she came over to ask if we were through with our paper. So then I had to relate the whole thing to the police, and they turned hostile so quickly, as if Iâd been withholding important evidence from them!â
Of course, to the police, this was important evidence. The fact that Diane couldnât see that only proved what Iâd suspected about her when Iâd met her: Diane Morgenstern was no rocket scientist. I was willing to bet that she neverread crime fiction, either. If she had, sheâd have known that any such revelation would make the police suspicious.
All the incident really proved was that Diane was out of touch with popular culture, in the reading-and-television-watching category.
âWhen did you move to Memphis?â Tolliver asked.
âAbout a year ago,â Joel said. âWe couldnât wait there, in that house, any