âOh, Morgan. You have a funny sense of time, you do. Itâs not been a long time, itâs been a lifetime, Tomâs lifetime. My lifetime, dammit. And in some ways it seems like yesterday. I can still see you on that black horse, riding away like youâd be back in an hour. Why, Morgan? Was I so bad? Was it so bad having a family, is that why you left?â
Atwater stared down at his hands crawling restlessly across the bare wood of the table. When he spoke, he didnât look up. âNo, Katie, it wasnât so bad.â
Kate barely heard him. He knew it, but he wasnât going to say it again unless she asked. As he knew she would. âI didnât hear that,â she said.
âI said no. It wasnât that.â
He looked up at her now, fearful of what he might see. He knew she hated him, and believed she was right to hate him. But he wanted her to understand. He had only just come to understand it himself, and he wasnât yet comfortable with the knowledge. Never very good at explaining things, he knew he had to try, because this was his one chance.
âI want to understand, you know. I think I have that right.â
âYou do. I donât know if I can . . . hell . . .â
âTalk to me, Morgan. Iâm the mother of your son.â
He took another sip of the coffee, already growing cold where it sat in the big mug. âMaybe thatâs why, Katie. Maybe I . . .â
She blew up then. âThatâs not why and you know it.â
âGive me a chance. You want to know, and I want to tell you.â
âYou had fifteen years to rehearse, Morgan. I should think youâd have it all set by now.â
He smashed a big fist on the table. âDamn it!â The mugs jumped an inch or so, and hers, untouched, sloshed coffee over its lip. The warm coffee lay there in a small dark pool, still steaming a little. They both watched the tiny coils of mist. âI never liked myself much, didnât like what I was turning into. I wanted to be something different, something you and the boy could be proud of. But that wasnât possible. Not then.â
âYou could have changed. You just didnât want to.â
âThey wouldnât let me.â
âThey. Whoâs they, Morgan? Who do you want to blame it on?â
âI blame myself, no one else. But it wasnât just me. You donât wake up one morning and say, âItâs a beautiful day. I think Iâll pretend I never owned a gun.â You canât do that, Katie. I couldnât, anyway. Because thereâs always someone out there who wonât let you forget. Sure, I could have stayed here. But one day, maybe in a week, maybe a month, somebody would have ridden up to the front door with one thing on his mind.â
âOh, youâre a mind reader now, too, are you? You can read the minds of people you never even met. Read them before they even got here. Is that how it is?â
âI . . .â
He stopped when he heard a footstep on the porch. His hand was on his gun before he realized what he was doing. Kate saw it, and he saw that she did. She shook her head. âYou havenât changed at all, have you?â
âYes, I have.â
âSo, you think your own son is going to shoot you?â
Morgan was stunned. She had said the boy was coming back, but not when. He hadnât expected him so soon. He wasnât ready. His eyes darted to her face. He hoped she would understand and offer him something, some way out. Katie smiled a bitter smile.
âThe gunfighter.â There was such contempt in her voice he wondered that it didnât sear the flesh from her lips as she spoke. âI wonât let you hide, I wonât let you run away. Not this time. Not until youâve done what you came for, whatever that is.â
Atwater stood, but his knees were like liquid. He tottered and was worried she
Marguerite Henry, Bonnie Shields