of unemployment insurance. Dullman claims he averaged fourteen, fifteen hosts a year. He must have had a hard time keeping track. Go on, Joan.â
âI was sixteen, and Foster Benedict had been my secret crush for years,â Joan said in a low voice. âWhen I read in the Record that he was staying at Mr. Bluefieldâs I did a very silly thing. I phoned him.â
She flushed. âYou can imagine the conversationâhow much I admired his work, my stage ambitions ⦠He must have been having a dull time, because he said heâd like to meet me. I was in heaven. He began to take me out. Drives up to the lake. Moonlight readings ⦠I certainly asked for it.â
She sat forward nervously. âI guess it was like one of those old-time melodramasâthe handsome lecher, the foolish young girlâthe only thing missing was the mortgage. Would you believe that when he promised me a part in his next play I actually fell for it?â Joan laughed. And then he went away, and I wrote him some desperate love letters he didnât bother to answer, and I didnât see or hear from him again until last night.
âAnd then when he made his royal entrance into the Playhouse, he not only didnât remember Wrightsville, or Mr. Bluefield, heâd forgotten me, too.â She was staring into the mirror of the time-polished floor. âI was a stranger to him. Just another scalp to add to his collection. Iâd meant so little to him not even my features had registered, let alone my name.â
âI warned you six years ago Benedict was poison,â Roger shouted, âbut would you listen? Ellery, if you knew how many times Iâve begged her to get off this acting kick and marry meââ
âLetâs get to you, Rodge. I take it your evasions last night covered up a prior acquaintance with Benedict, too?â
âHow could I explain without dragging Joan into it?â
âThen you met him at the same time.â
âI knew she was dating himâa high school kid!âand Iâd read of his weakness for the young ones. I was fit to be tied. I collared him one night after he took Joan home and I warned him to lay off. I said Iâd kill him, or some such juvenile big talk. He laughed in my face and I knocked him cold. He was sore as hell about itâIâd mussed up his precious profileâand he banged right down to headquarters to prefer charges of assault. That was when Dakin was chief. But then I guess Benedict had second thoughtsâbad publicity, or something. Anyway, he dropped the charges and left town.â
âDid the brawl get into the Record? â
Roger shrugged. âIt was a one-day wonder.â
âAnd was Joan named in the story?â
âWell, yes. Some oaf at headquarters shot his mouth off. Dakin fired him.â
Ellery shook his head. âYou two are beyond belief. How did you expect to keep a thing like that from Newby? Last night when you denied having known Benedict, Joan, didnât you notice Newby send one of his men on an errand? Heâs a city-trained policemanâhe wouldnât take your word. Heâd check the Record morgue and his own headquarters files. He may even have phoned the New York City police to search Benedictâs apartmentâBenedictâs bragged often enough in print about his collection of feminine love letters.
âSo Newby either knows already, or heâll very soon learn, that you lied to him on a crucial question, and exactly what happened six years ago, and exactly why. Donât you see what youâve handed him on a silver platter?â
Joan was mute.
âFrom Newbyâs viewpoint thereâs a strong circumstantial case against you, Joan. Situated in the only other dressing room on that side of the theater, you had the best opportunity to kill Benedict without being seen. The weapon? You wouldnât have had to move a step out of your way en