it.â
âYouâre right, Jameson,â Creighton acknowledged. âA man who can bring himself to do that to one human being wonât hesitate to do it to another.â
Marjorie sighed. âI wasnât protecting Michael Barnwell, I was protecting his family. But I suppose weâre beyond that now.â
âWhoâs Michael Barnwell?â Jameson asked.
Marjorie and Creighton described the meeting with Michaelâs wife, Elizabeth, and the trail of clues that led them to the house.
âWhy didnât Mrs. Barnwell call the police?â the detective quizzed.
âWhy didnât Mrs. Barnwell call the police?â Marjorie mimicked. âShe did call the police, but they dismissed it as a domestic dispute.â
âWell you should have called us the minute she showed up on your doorstep,â he chided.
âYes,â Creighton interjected, âbecause we all know how quickly you act upon Marjorieâs intuition.â
âCareful,â Jameson warned. âThereâs no need for this to get personal. Iâm just saying that you could have called us before you started traipsing around a crime scene, destroying potential evidence.â
âYeah,â Noonan interjected, âwhat gives with the bathroom? Thereâs about two inches of water on the floor.â
âOh, that?â Marjorie replied as innocently as she could. âThatâs um ⦠um â¦â
âDetective!â At once, a uniformed policeman appeared carrying a soaking wet navy blue dress shoe with what resembled a pair of giant tweezers. âDetective, we found what was causing the flood in the bathroom.â
Jameson took the tweezers from the young man. âHmmm. Why would someone try to flush a shoe? If itâs a clue, why not burn it? Unless they wanted us to find it â¦â
âExcuse me,â Marjorie pardoned herself as she surreptitiously grabbed the shoe.
âWhat are you doing? Thatâs evidence!â
âNo, Iâm afraid it isnât. Itâs mine.â
âYours? How did your shoe get in theâ?â
âThe same way lemon drops adhere to dogsâ hindquarters and Model Ts appear in rearview mirrors every time sheâs around,â Creighton explained. âI call it The Magic of Marjorie.â
âI call it screwy,â Noonan opined.
âI call it a waste of four dollars,â Marjorie said with disgust. âI loved these shoes!â
Jameson held up both hands as if directing traffic. âI donât care what any of you call it. I want to get to the bottom of this.â
Creighton smirked. âIf you found Marjorieâs shoe, you already have.â
Jameson huffed impatiently.
âPardon the pun, but Iâm quite serious. If Marjorieâs shoe hadnât gotten flushed, we might never have gone down to the cellar. I was looking for the main shutoff valve for the plumbing when we discovered that the key that was in Michael Barnwellâs pocket open ed the lock on the basement doors.â
âAnd inside?â the detective probed. âDid you happen to find anything inside the house that I should know about? After all, you two arenât above pocketing evidence.â
Marjorie was indignant. âWe didnât âpocketâ anything. There was nothing to pocketânot a clue to be found. Oh, except the suitcase.â
âSuitcase?â
âYes, the set by the back door. Thereâs a suitcase missing.â
âHow do you know itâs missing?â
âBecause I saw a similar set at Foxâs Department Store. They come in a set of four. If you look at Veronica Carterâs set, thereâs only three.â
Noonan shrugged. âSo? Veronica Carter packed her suitcase and left with Michael Barnwell.â
âThereâs two problems with that theory,â Marjorie stated. âFirst, Veronicaâs neighbor, Mrs. Sullivan, claims