And she replied that the Benandanti would come back for you when you were old enough to make the decision for yourself. That night, I told your father that I wanted to move to America.â
I pressed my hands to the sides of my head, trying to wrestle this knowledge in with all the other secrets Iâd been keeping. âDid Dad know?â I asked, finally saying aloud the question that had haunted me for months. âDid he know about the Benandanti?â
Lidia nodded. My chest squeezed tight, and I couldnât say the thing I feared most. Had he been a Benandante too?
âHe knew about them because both of his parents were Benandanti.â
I came off my knees and eased away from her. I had no memory of my paternal grandparents; I had always been told that they died when I was a baby. That was why my dad had returned to Twin Willows with his new wife and child: to run the farm that they had left behind. âDid they . . . die in battle?â
Lidia swallowed hard. Her eyes were shiny with tears threatening to spill over. âYes. It happened about six months after we came to Twin Willows.â
Six months. So I had met my grandparents. Or rather, they had met me. Try as I might, the only image of them I could conjure in my head was the picture of them, kind-faced and surrounded by goats, that we had on the mantel at home. My brain spun as all the pieces of the puzzle finally began clicking into place. That was why Nerina had built her lair on our farm, why sheâd placed the amulet in the basement of the farmhouse. Bree didnât know how right sheâd been when she once called my home Benandanti Central.
âBut Dad had to have known that they would find me here, too. The Waterfall in the woods behind our houseâthatâs the site of magic weâre protecting. He knew about it; he used to take me there. Why did you come back here to Twin Willows if you knew they were here, too?â
Lidia closed her eyes. Now the tears did spill over, staining her cheeks. âBecause he didnât agree with me,â she said, so low that I had to lean in to hear her. âBecause he knew that you would be a great Walker. That you would be a hero. He did not believe that you could escape that destiny, no matter where we were.â
God, that word, destiny . I could never escape it, no matter how hard I tried. âSo Iâve just been fulfilling some master plan all along?â I pushed myself up to my feet and paced the length of the couch. âYou all knew that I was going to be a Benandante someday, didnât you?â
âAlessia, I never wanted this for you. I had hoped it would never come to this, or if it did, that you would make the same choice I did. That you would refuse.â
I whirled to a stop in front of Lidia. âThe cowardâs choice?â
She winced. A stab of guilt pierced my gut, but I was too angry to really feel its pain. âHow long have you suspected that I was a Benandante?â
âI . . . I donât know . . . maybe a couple of months . . .â
âA couple of months ?â I tore my hands through my hair. âAnd you didnât say anything to me?â
âI knew that you would not be allowed to talkââ
âBut I couldâve talked to you!â I flung my arm in the direction of the living room. âJennyâs known her dad was a Benandante since she was twelve. Barb knows. Dad obviously knew about his parents. It seems like I was the only one in the Clan following the rules, and I was the one who most needed to break them.â I couldnât breathe; the anger and frustration were like bands across my ribs.
â Cara . . . â
âDonât cara me! I needed you and I was so afraid to say anything, afraid for your safety. And now I find out you knew all along.â I was surprised to taste salted tears in my mouth; I hadnât realized Iâd started crying. âIf you had come to me,