invited him to dinner one evening soon after he came home. Father had always been fond of Garth, and he did not see, as I saw, how much Garth had changed. Garth was more gentle to father than he was to other people, more considerate, less cynical. He had always been devoted to father. I decided that evening to wear my yellow frockâthe one I had worn at the danceâit had lain in my drawer for five years, wrapped in tissue paper. I took it out that evening when Garth was coming and looked at itâthere were tears in my throatâI had been so happy, wearing that frock. It was all gone now, that happiness, the war had killed it. Garth had loved me in that frock. Could it bring back the past? I thought perhaps it might. I thought perhaps the years would fall away and vanish as though they had not been.
Garth arrived before I was ready, I heard him talking to father in the drawing room, and I went in to greet him. He turned toward me as I came in and for a moment his face brightened, the cynical expression faded and he was the old Garth.
And then he bowed in a mocking manner. âYou never told me it was a party.â
âJust you, Garth,â I told him, with my heart fluttering in my breast like a trapped bird.
âI am honored indeed,â he mocked. âYou put me to shame with your grandeur. Why was I not told it was a full dress occasion so that I could have taken my dress suit out of moth-cake and had it pressed?â
Father looked up at me. âA pretty dress,â he said in his frail, threadlike voice. âA pretty dress, Charlotte.â
âYou think so, sir,â Garth said, looking at me gravely. âI might have thought it pretty at one time perhaps; it is odd how oneâs tastes change.â
I could say nothing to him, and he could thrust the knife into my heart and twist it with savage joy. I could only stand there and bear it as best I might.
Kitty ran into the room like a spring breeze. She had chosen to wear a simple white frockâa little girl frock with a high neck and long sleevesâshe swept me a curtsy and cried gaily.
âLa laâhow grand we are tonight!â
They gave me no peace all the evening. It was good-natured chaff on the surface, but beneath it, in Garthâs case, there was a strange bitterness that I could not understand. Kitty did not know the significance of the yellow frock, she did not know that every word went through my heart, but Garth knew. Garth was being deliberately cruel, he was torturing me. How I wished that I had not been prompted to wear that dressâI longed to run upstairs to my room and tear it off, but I couldnât do that, I had to brave it out, I had to sit and smile and pretend that I didnât mind. I pretended I had put on the yellow frock for a joke. It was a funny old-fashioned rag, I said; the fashions were more sensible now. I had put it on to let them see what frights we looked in the days before the war.
I realized that night that all was over between me and Garthâit could never come right now. Garth had gone from me forever. But I had not bargained that he would turn from me to Kittyâwhen I heard of their engagement something died in my heart. I loved Kitty, and I loved Garthâyes, in spite of all that had happened, I still loved himâand now they were both lost to meâboth lost.
They were married very quietly in Hinkleton Church. We need not linger here. I shall not tell you about the wedding, Clare, I canât. It was a blur of pain. I moved through the days of preparation like a ghost. You can imagine the wedding as you pleaseâthe presents, the flowers, the music, the eager crowd of tenants and villagers waiting to see the bride. Father married them and they went away. It was the last service that father took; the last time he was in his beloved church. He became very ill after Kitty had gone and only stayed with me a few days. I am sure he was glad to go. The