Hollywood and beyond believed that Peltier had been wrongly convicted, and Geffen was joined in his appeal for a pardon by Nelson Mandela and the Dalai Lama as well as by such smooth operators as Archbishop Desmond Tutu and the Reverend Jesse Jackson.
Clinton ignored Geffenâs request.
And as anyone in Hollywood could tell you, you didnât cross David Geffen without paying a price.
The Dowd interview was Geffenâs payback.
âMarc Rich getting pardon?â Geffen scoffed. âAn oil-profiteer expatriate who left the country rather than pay taxes or face justice? Yet another time when the Clintons were unwilling to stand for the things that they genuinely believe in. Everybody in politics lies, but they do it with such ease, itâs troubling.â
When that phrase ââthey do it [lie] with such ease, itâs troublingâ âappeared in black and white in Dowdâs column, it ricocheted from coast to coast and instantly became part of political lore. It was a reminder of William Safireâs famous opening sentence about Hillary in a 1996 Times column:âAmericans of all political persuasions are coming to the sad realization that our First Ladyâa woman of undoubted talents who was a role model for many in her generationâis a congenital liar.â
By early December 2007, Barack Obama had captured the lead in the Iowa polls, and Oprah Winfrey was drawing record crowds at Obama campaign rallies.
Panic broke out among Hillaryâs donors. Rumors began flying of a shake-up in her unruly and famously unmanageable staff. Reporters started writing eulogies for Hillaryâs campaign.
Hillary responded by calling in the cavalry: Bill Clinton.
With the presidential caucuses just two weeks away, she and Bill started making joint appearances at coffee shops and diners all across Iowa. She dropped her objection to using her mother, Dorothy, and daughter, Chelsea, in TV commercials. And just before Christmas, she embarked on what a New York Times headline writer with a droll sense of humor described as a âLikability Tour.â
This is how the Times played it:âMrs. Clinton has embarked this week on a warm-and-fuzzy tour, blitzing full throttle by helicopter across Iowa to present herself as likable and heart-warming, a complement to her âstrength and experienceâ message that the campaign felt a female candidate needed first.â
After Hillary lost to Obama in Iowa (she came in third after Obama and John Edwards), she mused about the outcome of the campaign.
âMaybe,â she said, âthey just donât like me.â
There was no maybe about it.
When Hillary got to New Hampshire, the site of the first primary in the nation, she reverted to form. She was spitting mad over her loss to Obama in Iowa, and she was eager to demonstrate that she wasnât intimidated by Obamaâs Chicago-style brass-knucklespolitics. As her mother, Dorothy, might have said: âThereâs no room in this campaign for cowards.â
During their final debate in the Granite State, Hillary came across as defensive and angryâher old default expression when speaking in public.
âMaking change is not about what you believe, itâs not about a speech you make,â she said, taking a shot at Obama, a first-term U.S. senator who, she believed, was riding on a smile and a shoe-shine and a lot of hot air.
The moderator caught Hillaryâs negative vibes and asked about her âpersonality deficit.â
How would she respond to voters who thought Obama was more likeable than she was?
âWell,â she replied, âthat hurts my feelings, but Iâll try to go on.â
Then she turned to Obama and added, âHeâs very likeable. I agree with that. I donât think Iâm that bad.â
But Obama wouldnât let Hillary off the hook.
âYouâre likeable enough, Hillary,â he said, throwing her some