effective barrier. Should the vortex weaken, the pressure rises near the poles
and falls in the middle latitudes, leading to frequent outbreaks of polar air. In
the Northern Hemisphere, scientists have defined the North Atlantic Oscillation index
to describe this seesaw of pressures between the poles and the middle latitudes, with
a high index associated with a strong vortex.
Because the aerosol cloud from Tambora heated the stratosphere in the middle latitudes,
but not in the Arctic, it enhanced the stratospheric westerly winds around the polar
vortex. This effect soon made its way from the stratosphere to the troposphere, strengthening
the barrier to Arctic air and leading to a stronger than normal high-pressure system
in the Atlantic Ocean near the Azores Islands. The unusually warm winter throughout
New England likely resulted from fewer incursions of polar air into the region. Data
from tree rings and other proxies for temperature indicate that the average winter
temperature in 1815–16 was as much as three degrees Fahrenheit warmer than normal
in a band extending southwest from Alaska through central and southern Canada, across
the Great Lakes, and into New England.
By strengthening the polar low and the Atlantic high-pressure system, the aerosol
cloud also accelerated the trans-Atlantic westerly jet stream that steers weather
systems from North America towards Europe. The jet stream also shifted north, bringing
more systems to central and northern Europe and fewer to the Mediterranean Sea and
North Africa. The westerly inflow of air from the Atlantic provided a steady source
of moisture for these systems, which released that moisture over Europe in a series
of snow- and rainstorms. The aerosol cloud effectively increased the North Atlantic
Oscillation index; as weather forecasters are well aware, high values of this index
are often associated with stormy winters across northern and central Europe. Using
climate models to simulate the effects of past volcanic eruptions, scientists have
found a consistent link between large eruptions and increases in the index the following
winter, with the models producing a nearly constant stream of storms across the Atlantic
as a result. The unsettled conditions across Europe in the winter of 1815–16 were
likely the result of the aerosol cloud’s effect on the North Atlantic Oscillation.
Although the primary effect of the aerosol cloud was to cool global temperatures,
its strengthening of the wintertime Arctic vortex delayed the appearance of severely
cold temperatures in the United States. Once the long, polar winter night ended, however,
the vortex weakened. Sunlight returned to the Arctic, and the aerosol cloud began
to heat the stratosphere there as well as at lower latitudes. The westerly wind barrier
around the vortex largely vanished, and cold air became free to move away from the
pole—south, towards the United States and Europe. The cooling effects of the aerosol
veil again became dominant, setting the stage for a chilling spring and a disastrous
summer.
Nevertheless, the short-term effect of the mild winter of 1815–16 in the United States
was to fuel the ongoing debate over whether American winters were growing warmer.
Renowned Puritan cleric and naturalist Cotton Mather had first advanced this hypothesis
in the late seventeenth century, less than a hundred years after the first English
settlers arrived in Massachusetts Bay. “Our own Winters are, observably as Comfortably
Moderated since the Land has been Peopled, and Opened, of Late Years,” wrote Mather.
“Our Snows are not so Deep, and Long … and our Winds blow not such Rasours, as in
the Days of our Fathers when the Hands of the Good Men would Freeze unto the Bread
upon their Tables.” (Occasionally Mather veered into flights of hyperbolic excess
in describing the rigors of winters past; he once claimed that when his