about where I was going or what I was doing. I - wouldnât call now, either. Let him stew. Heâd walked out on my high school graduation . . . and even though I hadnât been sure I really wanted him there, even though I was glad to sidestep his meeting Viv, it still wasnât right of him to have walked out.
No. Actually, I just didnât want to tell him I was with Dr. Wyatt when I should have been with him. I was vaguely ashamed. But it wasnât my fault.
The waiter arrived with water and a bread basket. âSomething to drink?â
I was about to ask for a Coke, but Dr. Wyatt waved the wine list. âWeâll have this 1995 Brunello di Montalcino.â He turned to me. âItâs a nice Italian red.â
âUh, sure,â I said after a second. I didnât want to appear unsophisticated, and if the waiter didnât notice that I was under the legal drinking ageâand because of my size, people did tend to think me older than I wasâI wouldnât mention it. It was only wine. Still, I wasnât sure I wanted to drink ever again in my lifetime. I hadnât had any alcohol since the night I had fought with my father, polished off his dusty bottle of scotch, and then emailed Dr. Wyatt.
Luckily the waiter had already provided big glasses of water.
âAn appetizer?â asked the waiter.
âLetâs try the coconut shrimp,â said Dr. Wyatt. âAnd a plate of the frogsâ legs. Oh, and maybe the blue cheese, pear, and walnut salad. Two plates and serving spoons so we can both try everything.â
The waiter departed. I hoped Iâd be allowed to choose my own dinner. I said to Dr. Wyatt, âUh, I might not have any frogsâ legs.â
âOf course you will. You should go through life seeking out new and different experiences, especially when youâre young. It broadens the mind. What? Whatâs that expression? What are you thinking?â
I shrugged. âItâs just that, well, you hear that a lot. About the importance of a broad mind. We hear it all the time at school, for example.â
âSo?â
âSoâwell, Viv and Iâyou met Viv todayâhad this conversation recently. Isnât it possible that there are times when youâd want people not to have broad minds? When it would be an advantage to be, oh, narrow and provincial?â
Dr. Wyatt leaned forward. âSuch as?â
âWell, suppose itâs wartime. If orders really need to be followed, then it would not be helpful for soldiers to have knowledge, say, of the enemyâs culture. That knowledge would just make you feel terrible about what you have to do. And in some cases, it might make you question your ordersâmight make you disobey.â
âYes,â Dr. Wyatt said. âItâs one reason why military training de-emphasizes individuality and emphasizes the importance of the team, the group, and of the order of command. Following orders has to be made instinctual and automatic.â
âRight,â I said. The wine arrived and Dr. Wyatt went through the tasting ceremony with the waiter, who then deftly poured a glass for each of us. The whole process took time, and I found myself thinking that I couldnât remember how long it had been since Iâd had an intellectual conversation with an adult.
Once upon a time, Iâd talked with my parents this way, of course, but no longer.
Now I felt the words and ideas gather pressure inside me. Finally, the waiter left. Dr. Wyatt steepled his hands on the table and leaned toward me.
âSo,â he said. âYou interest me greatly, Eli. Soldiersâyou were saying . . .â
âThat soldiers are better off without too much broadening,â I said. âOr, at least thatâs what we would think. But Iâve wonderedâlisten, do you like science fiction?â
Dr. Wyatt nodded. âMost people in the sciences do.â
âOkay,